透過您的圖書館登入
IP:54.198.45.0
  • 學位論文

公司之內控機制-以監察人為中心兼論審計委員會制度之設計

The Internal Control Mechanism of Corporations—Focused on the Supervisory System and with a Parallel Discussion on the design of Audit Committee

指導教授 : 賴英照
若您是本文的作者,可授權文章由華藝線上圖書館中協助推廣。

摘要


我國2006年證券交易法引進獨立董事組成審計委員會取代監察人,試圖解決我國公司內控失靈的困境,並由審計委員會行使監察人權限,但若我國監察人不能發揮應有之監督功能,由審計委員會行使監察人權限,就能發揮應有的監督功能嗎? 我國公司內控失靈的問題,癥結在於監察人之獨立性及專業性不足,而監察人的當選必須仰賴董事之支持,係造成其獨立性不足之主因。審計委員會是由獨立董事所組成,獨立董事仍由股東會所選任,在不改變選任方式之前,獨立董事之獨立性仍然不足,尚無法擺脫監察人不能發揮應有之監督功能的困境。 又立法者為方便起見,以全部準用之方式,將原先適用於監察人之規定,於審計委員會準用之。但我國公司法本來是雙軌制,由股東會分別選任董事及監察人,分掌公司業務之執行與監督,兩者立於平行地位。而審計委員會為單軌制下之產物,係下設於董事會之功能性委員會,協助董事會監督經營團隊,董事會與審計委員會係上下隸屬關係,由董事會下設之審計委員會行使本屬平行於董事會之監察人職權,來監督董事會,將會造成制度上的扞格!另立法者再賦予個別獨立董事核心監察權,創設審計委員會與獨立董事雙監察主體之制度,其間的衝突,恐使公司莫所適從。 因此,本文認為應回歸原本之雙軌制,強制累積投票制之適用,並且不得採交錯任期以削弱累積投票制之功能,以擔保監察人之獨立性,並由監察人任免簽證會計師及內部稽核主管,使監察人得以充分發揮財務業務監督之功能,並解決監察人「有將無兵」的窘境,補其專業性上之不足。

並列摘要


In 2006, for the purpose to resolve the situation of failure of internal control of corporate, Taiwan adopted the audit committee constituted by independent directors to replace the supervisor system in the Securities Exchange Act. However, if the supervisor system cannot provide effective function, will the audit committee can? The main reason for the failure of internal control is due to the lack of independence and expertise, and that is because the election of supervisor must be supported by the directors, the controlling shareholders. While the audit committee which is constituted by independent directors, and while independent directors are also supported by the controlling shareholders and directors, before the process of election changed, the lack of independence remains. For convenience, the legislators applied mutatis mutandis all the supervisor system to the audit committee without newly statutes. However, before the amendment, the shareholders elect the directors and supervisors in the same meeting by the same shareholders, which is a parallel two-tier system. But the audit committee is the one-tier system product, which is a function committee under the board and provides assistance function only. Expecting the audit committee to monitoring the board will cause a conflict of the system. By the way, the legislators grant each member of the audit committee has the core supervisor authority , that will create a dual supervisor system constituted by audit committee as a whole and the independent directors. It will increase the difficulty for the corporate to apply the newly amended provisions. In this thesis, the author suggests to go back to the two-tier system plus with the cumulative voting procedure and also the staggered board is forbade to make sure the independence of the supervisors. Meanwhile, the supervisors shall have the authority to designate the certified public accountant and the chief internal audit manager to resolve the lack of expertise for the two-tier system.

參考文獻


# 吳樂群發言,<「如何發揮監察人對公司業務與內控監督功能研討會」紀實>,《會計研究月刊》,第161期,1999年4月。
# 許永邦發言,<「如何發揮監察人對公司業務與內控監督功能研討會」紀實>,《會計研究月刊》,第161期,1999年4月。
# 王志誠,<董事會功能性分工之法制課題>,《政大法學評論》,第92期,2006年8月。
# 柯芳枝,<日本法上外部監察人制度之探討>,《台大法學論叢》,第25卷第1期,1995年10月。
# 王文宇,<設立獨立董監事對公司治理的影響>,《法令月刊》,第56卷第1期,2005年1月。收錄於氏著《公司與企業法制(二)》,元照,2007年1月。

被引用紀錄


陳(2016)。金融業監察人制度與審計委員會制度對於內控缺失之影響〔碩士論文,淡江大學〕。華藝線上圖書館。https://doi.org/10.6846%2fTKU.2016.00740
張坤釧(2016)。農田水利會多角化經營內部控制機制建構之研究:以都市型農田水利會為個案〔碩士論文,淡江大學〕。華藝線上圖書館。https://doi.org/10.6846%2fTKU.2016.00716
謝祐昀(2014)。論我國公開發行公司內部監控制度之課題─以監察人及審計委員會為中心〔碩士論文,國立臺灣大學〕。華藝線上圖書館。https://doi.org/10.6342%2fNTU.2014.10091
李姵萱(2013)。監察人與審計委員會於公司治理之角色〔碩士論文,國立臺灣大學〕。華藝線上圖書館。https://doi.org/10.6342%2fNTU.2013.00943
莊雯棋(2012)。我國單軌制下董事會功能定位之建構---兼論審計委員會之權限與責任〔碩士論文,國立中正大學〕。華藝線上圖書館。https://www.airitilibrary.com/Article/Detail?DocID=U0033-2110201613510758

延伸閱讀