臺灣人文學文獻引用類型分析研究

Citation Type Analysis on Humanity Literature of Taiwan

蔡明月(Ming-Yueh Tsay) ； 邱琦茹(Chi-Ju Chiu)

《教育資料與圖書館學》 51卷3期 (2014/04) Pp. 337-364

https://doi.org/10.6120/JoEMLS.2014.513/0594.RS.AM

摘要

本研究利用引用文獻分析法，針對國內人文學各學科頂尖期刊，以2011年所出版研究性文章為樣本，探討其論文結構與引用文獻出現在文章中的位置。再者，進一步採用Frost模式，分析各學科引用類型以及國內外引用類型的異同。本研究結果發現，國內文史哲藝術四門人文學科以論述型文獻為主，語言學以結構型文獻為主。論述型文章的引用文獻以本文部分最多，結論最少；結構型文章之引用文獻則是緒論部分最多，研究方法次之。人文學大多引用作品原著的首次作品，引用類型以支持作者意見或事實描述為主。整體而言，國內外引用類型分布大致相似，不同之處各學科略有差異。本研究結果可以了解人文學學者的引用特性與資訊需求，進而提升圖書館相關服務。再者，亦可增進人文學者對引用文獻本質的認識，並期望為未來相關實證研究提供參考。

關鍵字

人文學 ； 引用類型 ； 期刊論文結構 ； 引用位置 ； 引用文獻分析

並列摘要

Using informetrics and citation analysis, the present study explores and compares characteristics and types of citations in the humanity journal articles that published in Taiwan. Research articles published in 2011, from top humanity journals, assessed by the Institute of Humanities and Social Sciences, National Science Council in Taiwan, were collected and analyzed. The analysis was done by structure of journal article and location of citations. In addition to citations appearing in the text, the phenomena of citation type will be compared and discussed in the latter part. The results of this study revealed articles of literature, history, philosophy and arts were mostly argumentative, while linguistic articles tended to comply with IMRAD (Introduction, Methods and Materials, Results, And Discussion) formats. Introducing primary materials from original works, humanity scholars tended to cite for factual descriptions or to support authors' perspectives. Secondary materials, such as later studies on the original works by other scholars, were seen the most in the disciplines of linguistics while the least in that of history. In general, the distribution of citation types is similar between articles in domestic and foreign journals; merely minor differences occurred among disciplines. While citing characteristics and information needs of humanities scholars revealed in this study may contribute to collection development of libraries or refinement of information services to researchers, suggestions based on analysis of research results may also serve as reference for standardization of writing and publication of journal articles in Taiwan. Aiming at further exploration of citations, this study is expected to provide a better understanding of the nature of citations and to serve as a foundation for future empirical studies.

並列關鍵字

Humanity ； Citation type ； Journal article structure ； Classification of citation ； Citation analysis

參考文獻

陳光華(2009)。臺灣地區文學研究之引用分析。圖書資訊學刊。7(1/2)，1-36。

蔡明月、李旻嬑(2013)。臺灣社會科學引用文獻分析研究。教育資料與圖書館學。50(3)，293-318。

人文學科（無日期）。在大英百科全書。檢索自http://daying.wordpedia.com/content.aspx?id=035604

Humanities. (n.d.). In Encyclopeida Americana. Retrieved from http://ea.grolier.com.autorpa.lib.nccu.edu.tw/article?id=0208690

Archambault, E.,Gagné, E. V.(2004).The use of bibliometrics in the social sciences and humanities.,::Science-Metrix.