Translated Titles

Limited Renewal within CCP's Elite Circulation: A Trend Analysis on Political Elite Formation




黃信豪(Hsin-Hao Huang)

Key Words

中共 ; 政治菁英 ; 菁英活化 ; 政權演變 ; 量化分析 ; China ; political elite ; elite renewal ; regime evolution ; quantitative



Volume or Term/Year and Month of Publication

53卷4期(2010 / 12 / 01)

Page #

1 - 33

Content Language


Chinese Abstract


English Abstract

This paper addresses the changes and continuities of political elite configuration in China's reform era based on a dataset for the top Chinese leaders who worked on province or ministry level positions (and above) within the party or the government from 1978 to 2008. By applying a series of trend analyses and quantitative modeling, this paper finds that even though a large number of technocrats were recruited for their professional background in response to the demand for economic modernization, the CCP was still selecting the party elites by way of screening elites' political credentials. Specifically, the findings show that (1) the government recruited technocrats earlier than the party did; (2) there has been a lasting gap in individual political credentials between the party elites and the government elites; (3) the CCP has constructed a systematic mode for elite selection and elite cultivation by means of’ party-position appointment. These patterns highlight the importance of political credentials, but can not be systematically explained by the previous literature, which was mostly derived from the social mobility analysis. Accordingly, the author provides a preliminary explanation of ”limited renewal” for the empirical findings, and discusses its implications on the regime evolution and political future in China.

Topic Category 社會科學 > 政治學
  1. 寇健文(2007)。既重用又防範的菁英甄補:中共海歸派高官的仕途發展與侷限。中國大陸研究,50(3),1-28。
  2. 寇健文(2007)。胡錦濤時代團系幹部的崛起:派系考量vs.幹部輸送的組織任務。遠景基金會季刊,8(4),49-95。
  3. 黃信豪(2009)。晉升,還是離退?中共黨政菁英仕途發展的競爭性風險分析。台灣政治學刊,13(1),161-224。
  4. 黃信豪(2007)。量化研究的比較問題邏輯:因果異質性與縣市行長選舉投票模型的建立。問題與研究,46(3),125-154。
  5. 趙建民、張鈞智(2006)。菁英循環與再生?十二大以來中共技術官僚的發展趨勢。中國大陸研究,49(2),69-97。
  6. 「中共中央組織部關於建立省部級後備幹部制度的意見」,人民網,檢索日期2007年11月18日,http://cpc.people.com.cn/GB/64162/71380/71387/71591/4855020.html
  7. 毛澤東,「培養無產階級接班人」,新華網,1964年6月16日,http://news.xinhuanet.com/ziliao/2005-02/01/content_2533909.htm
  8. 「中共政治菁英資料庫」,國立政治大學中國大陸研究中心,檢索日期2010年9月30日,http://ics.nccu.edu.tw/chinaleaders/index.htm。http://ics.nccu.edu.tw/chinaleaders/index.htm
  9. 「中國共產黨歷次全國代表大會數據庫」,人民網,檢索日期2010年9月30日,http://cpc.people.com.cn/GB/64162/64168/index.html。http://cpc.people.com.cn/GB/64162/64168/index.html
  10. Bachman, David(1992).The Limits on Leadership in China.Asian Surrey,32(11),1046-1062.
  11. Braungart, Richard G.(ed.),Braungart, Margaret G.(ed.)(1990).The Political Sociology of the State.Greenwich, Conn.:JAI Press.
  12. Chang, Gordon G.(2002).The Coming Collapse of China.London:Arrow.
  13. Czudnowski, Moshe M.(1983).Toward a Second Generation of Empirical Elite and Leadership Studies.Political Elites and Social Change: Studies of Elite Roles and Attitudes,Illinois:
  14. Dickson, Bruce J.,Rublee, Maria Rost(2000).Membership has Its Privileges: The Socioeconomic Characteristics of Communist Party Members in Urban China.Comparative Political Studies,33(1),87-112.
  15. Dittmer, Lowell.(1978).Bases of Power in Chinese Politics: A Theory and an Analysis of the Fall of the 'Gang of Four'..World Politics,31(1),26-60.
  16. Dittmer, Lowell,Wu, Yu-shan(1995).The Modernization of Factionalism in Chinese Politics.World Politics,47(4),467-494.
  17. Djilas, Milovan(1957).The New Class: An Analysis of the Communist Systems.New York:Praeger.
  18. Etzioni-halevy, Eva(ed.)(1997).Classes and Elites in Democracy and Democratization: A Collection of Readings.New York:Garland.
  19. Firebauge, Glenn(1997).Analyzing Repeated Surveys.Thousand Oaks, Calif.:Sage.
  20. Gilley, Bruce(2004).China's Democratic Future: How It Will Happen and Where It Will Lead.New York:Columbia University Press.
  21. Higley, John,Burton, Michael G.(1989).The Elite Variable in Democratic Transitions and Breakdowns.American Sociological Review,54(1),17-32.
  22. Higley, John,Lengyel, György(2000).Elite Configurations after State Socialism.Elites after State Socialism,Lanham, Md.:
  23. Konrád, George,Szelényi, Ivan(1979).The Intellectuals on the Road to Class Power.New York:Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
  24. Lee, Hong-yung.(1991).From Revolutionary Cadres to Party Technocrats in Socialist China.Berkeley, Calif.:University of California Press.
  25. Li, Bobai,Walder, Andrew G.(2001).Career Advancement as Party Patronage: Sponsored Mobility into the Chinese Administrative Elite, 1949-1996.American Journal of Sociology,106(5),1371-1408.
  26. Li, Cheng(2008).Will China's 'Lost Generation' Find Path to Democracy?.China's Changing Political Landscape: Prospects for Democracy,Washington, D.C.:
  27. Li, Cheng(2000).Jiang Zemin's Successors: The Rise of the Fourth Generation of Leaders in the PRC.China Quarterly,161,1-40.
  28. Li, Cheng(2001).The 'Shanghai Gang': Force for Stability or Cause for Conflict.China Leadership Monitor,2
  29. Li, Cheng(1994).University Networks and the Rise of Qinghua Graduates in China's Leadership.The Australian Journal of Chinese Affairs,32,1-30.
  30. Li, Cheng,White, Lynn(1990).Elite Transformation and Modern Change in Mainland China and Taiwan: Empirical Data and the Theory Technocracy.China Quarterly,121,1-35.
  31. Li, Cheng,White, Lynn(1998).The Fifteenth Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party: Full-fedged Technocratic Leadership with Partial Control by Jiang Zemin.Asian Survey,38(3),231-264.
  32. Li, Cheng,White, Lynn(2003).The Sixteenth Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party: Hu Gets What?.Asian Survey,43(4),553-597.
  33. Li, Cheng,White, Lynn(1988).The Thirteenth Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party: From Mobilizers to Managers.Asian Survey,28(4),371-399.
  34. Li, Wei,Pye, Lucian W.(1992).The Ubiquitous Role of the Mishu in Chinese Politics.China Quarterly,132,913-936.
  35. Linz, Juan J.(2000).Totalitarian and Authoritarian Regimes.Boulder, CO:Lynne Reinner.
  36. Nathan, Andrew J.(1973).A Factionalism Model for CCP Politics.China Quarterly,53,34-66.
  37. Nathan, Andrew J.(2003).China's Changing of the Guard: Authoritarian Resilience.Journal of Democracy,14(1),6-17.
  38. Pei, Minxi(2006).China's Trapped Transition: The Limits of Developmental Autocracy.Cambridge, Mass:Harvard University Press.
  39. Putnam, Robert D.(1976).The Comparative Study of Political Elites.Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey:Prentice-hall, Inc..
  40. Scalapino, Robert A.(ed.)(1972).Elites in the People's Republic of China.Seattle:University of Washington Press.
  41. Seligman, Lester C.(1964).Elite Recruitment and Political Development.Journal of Politics,26(3),612-626.
  42. Szelényi, Ivan(1987).The Prospects and Limits of the East European New Class Project: An Auto-critical Reflection on The Intellectuals on the Road to Class Power.Politics and Society,15(2),103-144.
  43. Szelényi, Ivan,Szelényi, Szonja(1995).Circulation or Reproduction of Elites during the Postcommunist Transformation of Eastern Europe: Introduction.Theory and Society,24(5),615-638.
  44. Tsou, Tang(2002).Chinese Politics at the Top: Factionalism or Informal Politics? Balance-of-power or a Game of Win All?.The Nature of Chinese Politics: From Mao to Jiang,New York:
  45. Tsou, Tang(1976).Prolegomenon to the Study of Informal Group in CCP Politics.China Quarterly,65,98-119.
  46. Turner, Ralph H.(1960).Sponsored and Contest Mobility and the School System.American Sociological Review,25(6),855-867.
  47. Walder, Andrew G.(1986).Communist Neo-Traditionalism.Berkeley:University of California Press.
  48. Walder, Andrew G.(1995).Career Mobility and Communist Political Order.American Sociological Review,60(3),309-328.
  49. Wu, Yu-shan(1997).From Reform to Bureaucratic Stability in the PRC.Issues & Studies,33(8),81-104.
  50. Zagoria, David S.(1984).China's Quiet Revolution.Foreign Affairs,62(4),879-904.
  51. Zang, Xiaowei(2004).Elite Dualism and Leadership Selection in China.New York:Taylor & Fransic.
  52. Zang, Xiaowei(2006).Technical Training, Sponsored Mobility, and Functional Differentiation: Elite Formation in China in the Reform Era.Communist and Post-communist Studies,39,39-57.
  53. Zhou, Xueguang(1995).Partial Reform and the Chinese Bureaucracy in the Post-Mao Era.Comparative Political Studies,28(3),440-468.
  54. 中共中央組織部編(1999)。黨政領導幹部統計資料匯編(1954-1998)。北京:黨建讀物出版社。
  55. 中共中央組織部編、中共中央黨史研究室編(2004)。中國共產黨歷屆中央委員大辭典(1921-2003)。北京:中共黨史出版社。
  56. 中共中央組織部編、中共中央黨校研究室編、中央檔案館編(2000)。中國共產黨組織史資料(1921-1997)。北京:中共黨史出版社。
  57. 中共中央組織部參照試行公務員制度辦公室編(1995)。參照國家公務員制度管理工作指導手冊。北京:黨建讀物出版社。
  58. 何虎生編、李耀東編、向常福編、蔣建華編(2003)。中華人民共和國職官志。北京:中國社會出版社。
  59. 吳玉山(2007)。宏觀中國:後極權資本主義發展國家—蘇東與東亞模式的揉合。黨國蛻變—中共政權的菁英與政策,台北:
  60. 林佳龍、徐斯儉(2004)。退化的極權主義與中國未來發展。未來中國—退化的極權主義,台北:
  61. 姜華宣編、張蔚萍編、肖甡編(2006)。中國共產黨重要會議紀事(1921-2006)。北京:中央文獻出版社。
  62. 浦興祖編(2005)。中華人民共和國政治制度。上海:人民出版社。
  63. 寇健文(2005)。中共菁英政治的演變:制度化與權力轉移,1978-2004。台北:五南出版社。
  64. 喻中(2008)。中國政治中正式規則與潛規則的相互關係。當代中國研究
  65. 楊繼繩(1998)。鄧小平時代:中國改革開放20年紀實。北京:中央編譯出版社。
  66. 鄧小平(1994)。鄧小平文選。北京:人民出版社。
  67. 蕭功秦(2002)。中國後全能型的權威政治。戰略與管理,6,82-88。
Times Cited
  1. 劉志豪(2012)。中國國民黨青年政治組織之研究--以國民黨青年團為例。臺灣師範大學政治學研究所學位論文。2012。1-153。
  2. 李侑潔(2013)。性別因素對中共政治菁英甄補影響之研究。中正大學戰略暨國際事務研究所學位論文。2013。1-128。