Title

組建「巡邏隊」-中共中央與省級紀檢菁英結構與流動分析

Translated Titles

Forming the CCP's "Police Patrols": The CCDI and Provincial CDIs Elite Structure and Mobility in China

DOI

10.6229/CPSR.202106_(71).0003

Authors

張執中(Chih-Chung Chang);楊博揚(Bo-Yang Yang)

Key Words

中紀委 ; 代理人 ; 省紀委書記 ; 習近平 ; 菁英政治 ; Agent ; CCDI ; Elite ; Provincial Secretaries of CDI ; Xi Jinping

PublicationName

政治學報

Volume or Term/Year and Month of Publication

71期(2021 / 06 / 01)

Page #

61 - 98

Content Language

繁體中文

Chinese Abstract

中國共產黨紀律檢查委員會(簡稱紀檢)與黨委員會(簡稱黨委)同為中國共產黨全國代表大會選舉產生,兼具政治與專業性,雖然在階層化的晉升競賽中並非屬於領先群,但中央卻有賴紀檢系統作為「巡邏隊」來監督部門與地方等「代理人」。本文主要檢視江澤民到習近平時期,中央與地方紀檢菁英結構與流動,試圖找出菁英結構背後的政策與制度關聯,同時也探討紀檢菁英的背景與經歷對政策執行的影響。從鄧小平恢復中央紀律檢查委員會(簡稱「中紀委」)到習近平推動國家監察體制改革,都顯示紀檢系統與核心領導人的密切關係。本文發現自江澤民時期,雖然開始推動中紀委的接班梯隊與專業化,也開始推動地方幹部的交流。不過,制度的擴散主要歷經胡錦濤到習近平的任期,包括紀檢全面駐點、紀檢與其他重要分口的連結,最終到國家監察委的建立。加上省級紀委書記的提名朝「異地交流」與「中央空降」為主流,將省級紀委書記由地方黨委任命的代理人,改造為中央監督地方黨委的巡邏隊。

English Abstract

The Commission for Discipline Inspection (CDI) and the Party Committee of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) are both elected by the Party Congress. Although the CDI elites are not the leading group in the promotion competition, but they have gradually become the key to CCP's internal control over the cadres ever since the era of Deng Xiaoping. In order to discover differences in the Central Commission for Discipline Inspection (CCDI) and Provincial CDI elites structure and mobility of Xi and his predecessors Jiang and Hu, this research collected and reviewed data on the personnel reshuffling of the CCDI and provincial secretaries of CDI, and to identify institutions or policies as key independent variables in explaining the elite mobility. This analysis contends that when it came to reforming the professionalism and succession in echelon of CCDI and the process for nominating provincial secretaries of CDI as early as Jiang Zemin's tenure. However, it was not until the period of Hu and Xi, that more than 90% of selection and appointment approaches were either through office exchanges between different locations or direct planting from the party center. The more frequent switching of the discipline-inspection secretaries of provincial commissions indicates that the center has become more reliant on discipline inspection commissions to monitor governments and party committees. Each of the above steps reflected a strong inclination to dictate the selection process for personnel reshufflings at all levels of the CDI in Xi's period.

Topic Category 社會科學 > 政治學
Reference
  1. Bo, Z.-Y.(2005).Political Succession and Elite Politics in Twenty-First Century China: Toward a Perspecative of ‘Power Balancing.Issues & Studies,41(1),162-189.
    連結:
  2. 寇健文(2007)。既重用又防範的菁英甄補:中共海歸派高官的仕途發展與侷限。中國大陸研究,53(4),1-28。
    連結:
  3. 寇健文(2007)。胡錦濤時代團系幹部的崛起:派系考量 vs. 幹部輸送的組織任務。遠景基金會季刊,8(4),49-95。
    連結:
  4. 寇健文,陳方隅(2009)。1978年以後中共財經高官的仕途流動:特徵與趨勢。政治學報,47,59-103。
    連結:
  5. 黃信豪(2010)。有限活化的中共菁英循環:黨政領導菁英組成的跨時考察。中國大陸研究,53(4),1-33。
    連結:
  6. 黃信豪(2009)。晉升,還是離退?中共黨政菁英仕途發展的競爭性風險分析,1978-2008。臺灣政治學刊,13(1),161-224。
    連結:
  7. Art, D.(2012).What Do We Know about Authoritarianism after Ten Years?.Com parative Politics,44(3),351-373.
  8. Bachman, D.(1992).The Limits on Leadership in China.Asian Survey,32(11),1046-1062.
  9. Edin, M.(2003).State Capacity and Local Agent Control in China: CCP Cadre Management from a Township Perspective.The China Quarterly,173,35-52.
  10. Eisenhardt, K. M.(1989).Agency Theory: An Assessment and Review.The Academy of Management Review,14(1),57-74.
  11. Fewsmith, J., 2015. “China’s Political Ecology and the Fight Against Corruption.” in China Leadership Monitor: https://www.hoover.org/sites/default/files/research/docs/clm46jf.pdf, Available: 2021/1/16.
  12. Geddes, B.(1999).What Do We Know about Democratization after Twenty Years?.Annual Review of Political Science,2,115-144.
  13. Gong, T.(2008).The Party Discipline Inspection in China: Its Evolving Trajectory and Embedded Dilemmas.Crime, Law and Social Change,49(2),139-152.
  14. Guo, X.(2014).Controlling Corruption in the Party: China’s Central Discipline Inspection Commission.The China Quarterly,219,597-624.
  15. Guo, Y.(2012).The Evolvement of the Chinese Communist Party Discipline Inspection Commission in the Reform Era.The China Review,12(1),1-23.
  16. Huang, Y.(2002).Managing Chinese Bureaucrats: An Institutional Economics Perspective.Political Studies,50(1),61-79.
  17. Kinkel, J. J.,Hurst, W. J.(2015).The Judicial Cadre Evaluation System in China: From Quantification to Intra-State Legibility.The China Quarterly,224,933-954.
  18. Kiser, E.(1999).Comparing Varieties of Agency Theory in Economics, Political Science, and Sociology: An Illustration from State Policy Implementation.Sociological Theory,17(2),146-170.
  19. Kou, C.(2017).Xi Jinping in Command: Solving the Principal–Agent Problem in CCP–PLA Relations?.The China Quarterly,232,866-885.
  20. Kou, C.,Tsai, W.-H.(2014).Sprinting with Small Steps’ towards Promotion: Solutions for the Age Dilemma in the CCP Cadre Appointment System.The China Journal,71,153-171.
  21. Landry, P. F.(2008).Decentralized Authoritarianism in China: The Communist Party’s Control of Local Elites in the Post-Mao Era.Cambridge, NY:Cambridge University Press.
  22. Lee, H.-Y.(1991).From Revolutionary Cadres to Party Technocrats in Socialist China.Berkeley, CA:University of California Press.
  23. Li ,C.,White, L.(1990).Elite Transformation and Modern Change in Mainland China and Taiwan: Empirical Data and the Theory of Technocracy.China Quarterly,121,1-35.
  24. Li, C.(2001).China’ Leaders: The New Generation.Lanham, MA:Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
  25. Li, C.(2000).China in 1999: Seeking Common Ground at a Time of Tension and Conflict.Asian Survey,40(1),112-129.
  26. Li, C.(2016).Holding ‘China Inc.’ Together: The CCP and the Rise of China’s Yangqi.The China Quarterly,228,927-949.
  27. Li, C.,White, L.(1998).The Fifteenth Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party: Full-Fledged Technocratic Leadership with Partial Control by Jiang Zemin.Asian Survey,36(3),231-264.
  28. Ma, S. K.(2008).The Dual Nature of Anti-Corruption Agencies in China.Crime, Law and Social Change,49(2),153-165.
  29. Manion, M.(1993).Retirement of Revolutions in China: Public Policies, Social Norms, Private Interests.Princeton, NJ:Princeton University Press.
  30. Pantsov, A. V.,Levine, S. I.(2015).Deng Xiaoping: A Revolutionary Life.New York:Oxford University Press.
  31. Policzer, P.(2009).The Rise and Fall of Repression in Chile.Notre Dame, IN:University of Notre Dame Press.
  32. Scalapino, R. A.(1972).Elites in the People’s Republic of China.Seattle, WA:University of Washington Press.
  33. Shih, V.,Shan, W.,Liu, M.(2010).The Central Committee, past and present: A Method of Quantifying Elite Biographies.Contemporary Chinese Politics: New Sources, Methods, and Field Strategies,New York:
  34. Sullivan, L. R.(1984).The Role of the Control Organs in the Chinese Communist Party, 1977–83.Asian Survey,24(6),597-617.
  35. Tsai, W.-H.,Kou, C.-W.(2015).The Party’s Disciples: CCP Reserve Cadres and the Perpetuation of a Resilient Authoritarian Regime.The China Quarterly,221,1-20.
  36. Wang, Y.(2014).Empowering the Police: How the Chinese Communist Party Manages Its Coercive Leaders.The China Quarterly,219,625-648.
  37. Wu, G.(2015).China’s Party Congress: Power, Legitimacy, and Institutional Manipulation.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  38. Yahuda, M.(1979).Political Generations in China.The China Quarterly,80,793-805.
  39. Zang, X.(2004).Elite Dualism and Leadership Selection in China.New York:RoutledgeCurzon.
  40. Zang, X.(2006).Technical Training, Sponsored Mobility, and Functional Differentiation: Elite Formation in China in the Reform Era.Communist and Post-Communist Studies,39(1),39-57.
  41. Zeng, Q.,Yang, Y.(2017).Informal Networks as Safety Nets: The Role of Personal Ties in China’s Anti-Corruption Campaign.China: An International Journal,15(3),26-57.
  42. Zuo, C. V.(2015).Promoting City Leaders: The Structure of Political Incentives in China.The China Quarterly,224,955-984.
  43. 人民網,2021,〈中國政要資料庫〉,中國政要資料庫:http://cpc.people.com.cn/BIG5/64162/394696/index.html。2021/1/20。
  44. 三實,2015,〈省級紀委書記的仕途前景〉,上觀新聞:https://www.jfdaily.com/wx/detail.do?id=3542。2019/1/30。
  45. 中共中央紀律檢查委員會、中華人民共和國國家監察委員會,n.d.-a,〈中央紀委國家監委網站〉,中央紀委國家監委網站:http://www.ccdi.gov.cn。2020/12/10。
  46. 中共中央紀律檢查委員會、中華人民共和國國家監察委員會,n.d.-b,〈中央紀委監察部機構內設機構及職責公布〉,中央紀委國家監委網站:http://www.ccdi.gov.cn/special/zzjgzt。2021/1/20。
  47. 中國社會科學院(編)(1997).中國共產黨黨內法規制度手冊.北京:紅旗.
  48. 中國經濟網,n.d.,〈地方黨政領導人物庫〉,地方黨政領導人物庫:http://district.ce.cn/zt/rwk/index.shtml。2021/1/20。
  49. 中國儲備糧管理總公司,2014,〈中國儲備糧管理總公司關於中央第一巡視組反饋意見整改情況的通報〉,中央紀委國家監委網站:http://www.ccdi.gov.cn/special/zyxszt/2013dyl_zyxs/zgls_dyl_zyxs/201402/t20140225_19083.html。2019/2/21。
  50. 中華人民共和國國務院,1982,〈中共中央、國務院關於打擊經濟領域中嚴重犯罪活動的決定〉,《中華人民共和國國務院公報》,1982年第8號,頁307-315。
  51. 孔明明,2014,〈1978年恢復中紀委內幕:陳雲力薦胡耀邦出任書記〉,搜狐網:https://history.sohu.com/20140410/n397970979.shtml。2019/5/4。
  52. 史文杰、王少偉、金頌,2014,〈改變,不只是排位—湖北明確紀委書記(紀檢組長)在領導班子中排序追蹤〉,《中國紀檢監察報》,2014/7/3:1版。
  53. 四川組工網,2005,〈中共中央紀律檢查委員會關於中央紀委派駐紀檢組和各部門黨組紀檢組(紀委)若干問題的規定(試行)〉,四川組工網:http://www.gcdr.gov.cn/content.html?id=16805。2020/6/1。
  54. 田彬彬,范子英(2016)。紀委獨立性對反腐敗力度的影響—來自省紀委書記異地交流的證據。經濟社會體制比較,2016(5),101-115。
  55. 任劍濤(2010)。黨權、異地任職與中央控制—從三個案例看地方治理的權力畸變與制度矯正。江蘇社會科學,2010(6),108-116。
  56. 安蘇(2004)。「張家界模式」受挫背後:一場紀委改革的中止。廉政瞭望,2004(2),10-11。
  57. 朱紅軍、趙一海,2008,〈「空降」紀委書記在上海留下了什麼〉,《南方週末》,2008/5/1:B10版。
  58. 江琳,2014,〈湖北加強反腐體制機制創新,明確紀委書記(紀檢組長)在領導班子中的排序〉,《人民日報》,2014/7/29:18版。
  59. 吳仁傑(2007)。中共調整省級紀委書記評析。展望與探索,5(3),127-134。
  60. 吳美華(2009)。中國共產黨紀檢機構的歷史沿革及其職能演變。中共黨史研究,2009(3),19-25。
  61. 呂振亞,2002,〈習近平稱,福建將加大打擊走私和偷渡的力度〉,中國新聞網:http://www.chinanews.com/2002-03-10/26/168352.html。2002/3/10。
  62. 李輝(2013).當代中國反腐敗制度研究.上海:上海人民出版社.
  63. 周雪光(2018)。中國地方政府官員的空間流動:層級分流模式與經驗證據。社會,38(3),1-45。
  64. 周黎安(2007)。中國地方官員的晉升錦標賽模式研究。經濟研究,2007(7),36-50。
  65. 林佳龍(編),邱澤奇(編)(1999).兩岸黨國體制與民主發展:哈佛大學東西方學者的對話.臺北:月旦.
  66. 姜萍萍、程宏毅,2013,〈中共中央印發《建立健全懲治和預防腐敗體2013-2017年工作規劃》〉,人民網:http://fanfu.people.com.cn/n/2013/1226/c64371-23947331.html。2020/12/26。
  67. 桂田田,2015,〈紀委書記是如何選拔:考察時看基本素質任職經歷〉,中國新聞網:http://www.chinanews.com/gn/2015/02-02/7023900.shtml。2015/2/2。
  68. 耿曙,鍾靈娜,龐保慶(2014)。遠近高低各不同:如何分辨省級領導的政治地位?。經濟社會體制比較,2014(5),82-95。
  69. 袁勃、趙綱,2014,〈山西人大副主任金道銘落馬遭省級機關老幹部合力舉報〉,人民網:http://politics.people.com.cn/BIG5/n/2014/0228/c1001-24487783.html。2020/2/26。
  70. 馬國英,2016,〈國家監察委員會揭幕!如何再造現有反腐機構?〉,人民網:http://politics.people.com.cn/n1/2016/1108/c1001-28845567.html。2020/11/8。
  71. 國立政治大學,2012,〈中共政治菁英資料庫〉,中共政治菁英資料庫:https://cped.nccu.edu.tw/。2020/12/30。
  72. 國家統計局,2017,〈國家統計局關於2017年糧食產量的公告〉,中華人民共和國國家統計局:http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjsj/zxfb/201712/t20171208_1561546.html。2017/12/8。
  73. 寇健文(2010).中共菁英政治的演變—制度化與權力轉移1978 ~ 2010.臺北:五南.
  74. 寇健文,蔡文軒(2012).瞄準十八大:中共第五代領導菁英.臺北:博雅書屋.
  75. 張執中(2008).中共黨國邊界的設定與延伸:歷史制度論的觀點.臺北:韋伯.
  76. 張蕾,2013,〈王岐山的知青歲月:與習近平交好同蓋一床被子〉,鳳凰網:http://hb.ifeng.com/news/focus/detail_2013_09/08/1198995_0.shtml。2020/9/2。
  77. 梁梓然(2018)。廈門大學政治學系。
  78. 曾金勝(2007)。「空降」紀委書記凸顯反腐新布局—訪中共中央黨校黨建教研部教授任鐵纓。人民論壇,2007(2),26-28。
  79. 新華社,2016,〈中共中央辦公廳印發《關於在北京市、山西省、浙江省開展國家監察體制改革試點方案》〉,新華網:http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2016-11/07/c_1119867301.htm。2021/1/22。
  80. 新華網,2021,〈習近平在十九屆中央紀委五次全會上發表重要講話強調充分發揮全面從嚴治黨引領保障作用確保「十四五」時期目標任務落到實處〉,新華網:http://www.xinhuanet.com/politics/leaders/2021-01/22/c_1127014957.htm。2021/1/22。
  81. 新華網,n.d.,〈人事任免〉,新華網:http://www.news.cn/politics/rsrm/zyrm.htm。2021/1/20。
  82. 賈玥、趙綱,2016,〈中央一級黨和國家機關實現派駐紀檢機構全覆蓋〉,人民網:http://politics.people.com.cn/BIG5/n1/2016/0105/c1001-28015866.html。2019/5/4。
  83. 過勇(2012)。新時期中國共產黨紀律檢查委員會的改革歷程。經濟社會體制比較,2012(5),130-144。
  84. 過勇,宋偉(2014)。中國地方紀檢監察機關改革模式分析。政治學研究,2014(5),11-24。
  85. 旗幟網,2018,〈黨政領導幹部交流工作規定〉,旗幟網:http://www.qizhiwang.org.cn/BIG5/n1/2018/1204/c422547-30441881.html。2020/12/26。
  86. 趙紫陽,1987,〈沿著有中國特色的社會主義道路前進〉,中國政府網:http://www.gov.cn/test/2008-07/01/content_1032279.htm。2020/7/1。
  87. 鳳凰網,2014,〈「反腐鬥士」曹克明去世曾查案牽出陳希同案〉,鳳凰網:http://news.ifeng.com/a/20140905/41879973_0.shtml。2019/9/5。
  88. 蔣建華,2010,《中國反腐倡廉大事記(1978 ~ 2010)上編》,人民網:http://dangshi.people.com.cn/BIG5/146570/198299/199543/199559/index.html。2020/10/20。
  89. 蔡正喆,楊其靜(2019)。紀委實際權威性與反腐力度:理論與實證。經濟學季刊,2019(1),167-192。
  90. 鄭赫南、于紅旗、趙寶倉,2013,〈中儲糧河南公司原董事長李長軒腐敗案思考〉,人民網:http://fanfu.people.com.cn/n/2013/0716/c64371-22207429.html。2020/7/16。