Title

Do Contacts Matter? Public Impressions of a Rising China in Taiwan

Translated Titles

接觸有效嗎?民衆對於崛起中國的普遍印象

DOI

10.6612/tjes.2017.24.01.01-31

Authors

吳重禮(Chung-li Wu)

Key Words

rising China ; contact theory ; group threat theory ; image of China ; social distance ; 中國崛起 ; 接觸理論 ; 團體威脅理論 ; 中國印象 ; 社會距離

PublicationName

選舉研究

Volume or Term/Year and Month of Publication

24卷1期(2017 / 05 / 01)

Page #

1 - 31

Content Language

英文

Chinese Abstract

The emergence of China as a first-tier world power is a critical issue both politically and economically, but what is often overlooked is how more frequent interaction with China influences public opinion. This study is aimed at assessing two competing approaches, "contact" theory and "group threat" theory, in an effort to understand how exposure to and contact with China influence Taiwanese citizens' impressions of China. More specifically, it focuses on how, as cross-Strait relations develop, the public in Taiwan may either have positive views or negative feelings toward China. Methodologically, in addition to the objective measurement of contact (exposure to China) employed in the previous literature, the paper uses a subjective measurement of contact (willingness to interact with China). This study analyzes both individual-level and aggregate-level datasets in the models; in doing this, it takes advantage of a 2014 nationwide telephone survey and considers the effects of the regional context. The findings demonstrate that the subjective measurement shows more variance in public opinion on China than the objective measure, and the contextual variables exert conditional influences upon Taiwanese people's overall disposition toward China. The results by and large confirm the validity of contact theory, but also indicate that it is too simplistic and straightforward, and therefore in need of revision. The data reveal that greater exposure is not enough to foster greater trust and cooperation between the two sides; it is increased willingness to interact that creates more favorable impressions.

English Abstract

中國崛起成為世界重要的強權國家,就政治和經濟而言,這無疑是個關鍵課題,然而與中國更多的交流互動如何影響民眾觀感,這項議題仍有待探索。本文旨在檢證兩個相互競逐的觀點,亦即「接觸理論」(contact theory) 和「團體威脅理論」(group threat theory),以試圖瞭解兩岸交流互動如何影響臺灣民眾對於中國的印象。更確切地說,本文聚焦於,隨著兩岸接觸益形頻繁密切之際,臺灣民眾對於中國的整體觀感,究竟產生正面效果還是負面認知?在研究方法方面,除了沿用既有學術文獻使用的客觀接觸測量(前往中國的次數)之外,本文採用主觀接觸測量(與中國互動的意願)。在研究模型方面,本文分析個人層級和集體層級的資料;前者為2014 年全國電話調查數據,後者則是縣市地區的脈絡效果。實證資料顯示,主觀接觸測量比客觀接觸測量更能解釋民眾的中國觀感;其次,地區脈絡變數對於臺灣民眾對於中國的整體認知,也有若干的解釋效果。整體而言,研究結果支持接觸理論的適用性,儘管如此,本文認為,該理論可能有流於簡化和直觀之虞,因此有其修訂之必要。相關數據證實,徒然增加雙方往來的頻繁次數,並不足以促進兩岸的信任和合作;反之,提升交流互動的主觀意願,始有助於提升彼此的正面觀感。

Topic Category 社會科學 > 政治學
Reference
  1. Bogardus, Emory S. 1933. “A Social Distance Scale.” Sociology and Social Research 17(January-February): 265-271.
  2. Lazarsfeld, Paul F., Bernard Berelson, and Hazel Gaudet. 1944. The People's Choice. New York: Duell, Sloan, and Pearce.
  3. Aldrich, John,Lu, Jie(2015).The Image of China in the West: How the Public in the US, Latin America, and East Asia Sees an Emerging China.European Review,23(2),227-241.
  4. Aldrich, John,Lu, Jie,Kang, Liu(2014).How do Americans View the Rising China?.Journal of Contemporary China,24(92),203-221.
  5. Alesina, Alberto,Ferrara, Eliana La(2002).Who Trusts Others?.Journal of Public Economics,85(2),207-234.
  6. Allport, Gordon W.(1979).The Nature of Prejudice.Garden City, NJ:Doubleday.
  7. Berelson, Bernard R.,Lazarsfeld, Paul F.,McPhee, William N.(1954).Voting.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
  8. Bobo, Lawrence D.(2002).Prejudice as Group Position: Microfoundations of a Sociological Approach to Racism and Racial Relations.Journal of Social Issues,55(3),445-472.
  9. Bonacich, Edna(1973).A Theory of Middleman Minorities.American Sociological Review,38(5),583-594.
  10. Brewer, Marilynn B.,Miller, Norman(1996).When Contact is Not Enough: Social Identity and Intergroup Cooperation.International Journal of Intercultural Relations,20(3/4),291-303.
  11. Byrnes, Deborah A.,Kiger, Gary(1988).Contemporary Measures of Attitudes toward Blacks.Educational and Psychological Measurement,48(1),107-118.
  12. Campbell, Angus,Converse, Philip E.,Miller, Warren E.,Stokes, Donald E.(1960).The American Voter.New York:John Wiley and Sons.
  13. Chao, Chien-min(2004).National Security vs. Economic Interests: Reassessing Taiwan's Mainland Policy under Chen Shui-bian.Journal of Contemporary China,13(41),687-704.
  14. Chao, Chien-min(2003).Will Economic Integration between Mainland China and Taiwan Lead to a Congenial Political Culture?.Asian Survey,43(2),280-304.
  15. Chu, Yun-han(2004).Taiwan's National Identity Politics and the Prospect of Cross-Strait Relations.Asian Survey,44(4),484-512.
  16. Chu, Yun-han,Kang, Liu,Huang, Min-hua(2015).How East Asians View the Rise of China.Journal of Contemporary China,24(93),398-420.
  17. Crandall, Christian S.(1991).Multiple Stigma and AIDS: Illness Stigma and Attitudes toward Homosexuals and IV Drug Users in AIDS-Related Stigmatization.Journal of Community & Applied Social Psychology,1(2),165-172.
  18. Delhey, Jan,Newton, Kenneth(2005).Predicting Cross-National Levels of Social Trust: Global Pattern or Nordic Exceptionalism?.European Sociological Review,21(4),311-327.
  19. Dixon, Jeffrey C.,Rosenbaum, Michael S.(2004).Nice to Know You? Testing Contact, Cultural, and Group Threat Theories of Anti-Black and Anti-Hispanic Stereotypes.Social Science Quarterly,85(2),257-280.
  20. Ellison, Christopher G.,Powers, Daniel A.(1994).The Contact Hypothesis and Racial Attitudes among Black Americans.Social Science Quarterly,75(2),385-400.
  21. Evans, Geoffrey,Need, Ariana(2002).Explaining Ethnic Polarization over Attitudes toward Minority Rights in Eastern Europe: A Multilevel Analysis.Social Science Research,31(4),653-680.
  22. Fell, Dafydd(2005).Party Politics in Taiwan.London:Routledge.
  23. Fienberg, Stephen E.(1980).The Analysis of Cross-Classified Categorical Data.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
  24. Giles, Michael W.,Buckner, Melanie(1993).David Duke and Black Threat: An Old Hypothesis Revisited.Journal of Politics,55(3),702-713.
  25. Glaser, James(1994).Back to the Black Belt: Racial Environment and White Racial Attitudes in the South.Journal of Politics,56(1),21-41.
  26. Gries, Peter Hays,Crowson, H. Michael,Sandel, Todd L.(2010).The Olympic Effect on American Attitudes towards China: Beyond Personality, Ideology, and Media Exposure.Journal of Contemporary China,19(64),213-231.
  27. Ha, Sheng E.(2010).The Consequences of Multiracial Contexts on Public Attitudes toward Immigration.Political Research Quarterly,63(1),29-42.
  28. Hsiau, A-chin(2000).Contemporary Taiwanese Cultural Nationalism.London:Routledge.
  29. Hsieh, John Fuh-sheng,Niou, Emerson M. S.(1996).Salient Issues in Taiwan's Electoral Politics.Electoral Studies,15(2),219-235.
  30. Huang, Min-hua,Chu, Yun-han(2015).The Sway of Geopolitics, Economic Interdependence and Cultural Identity: Why are Some Asians more Favorable toward China's Rise then Others?.Journal of Contemporary China,24(93),421-441.
  31. Huckfeldt, Robert,Ikeda, Ken'ichi,Pappi, Franz Urban(2000).Political Expertise, Interdependent Citizens, and the Value Added Problem in Democratic Politics.Japanese Journal of Political Science,1(2),171-195.
  32. Huckfeldt, Robert,Sprague, John,Levin, Jeffrey(2000).The Dynamics of Collective Deliberation in the 1996 Election: Campaign Effects on Accessibility, Certainty, and Accuracy.American Political Science Review,94(3),641-651.
  33. Jackman, Mary R.,Crane, Marie(1986).'Some of My Best Friends Are Black…': Interracial Friendship and Whites' Racial Attitudes.Public Opinion Quarterly,50(4),459-486.
  34. Lieberson, Stanley(1985).Making It Count: The Improvement of Social Research and Theory.Berkeley, CA:University of California Press.
  35. Liu, Kang,Chu, Yun-han(2015).China's Rise through World Public Opinion: Editorial Introduction.Journal of Contemporary China,24(92),197-202.
  36. McCullagh, P.,Nelder, J. A.(1989).Generalized Linear Models.London:Chapman and Hall.
  37. Miller, William L.(1977).Electoral Dynamics.London:Macmillan.
  38. Nye, Judith L.(ed.),Brower, Aaron M.(ed.)(1992).What's Social about Social Cognition?.London:Sage.
  39. Oliver, J. Eric,Wong, Janelle(2003).Intergroup Prejudice in Multiethnic Settings.American Journal of Political Science,47(4),567-582.
  40. Olzak, Susan(1992).The Dynamics of Ethnic Competition and Conflict.Stanford, CA:Stanford University Press.
  41. Page, Benjamin I.,Xie, Tao(2010).Living with the Dragon: How the American Public Views the Rise of China.New York:Columbia University Press.
  42. Pettigrew, Thomas F.(1998).Intergroup Contact Theory.Annual Review of Psychology,49(1),65-85.
  43. Powers, Daniel A.,Ellison, Christopher G.(1995).Interracial Contact and Black Racial Attitudes: The Contact Hypothesis and Selectivity Bias.Social Forces,74(1),205-226.
  44. Putnam, Robert D.(2000).Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community.New York:Simon & Schuster.
  45. Quillian, Lincoln(1996).Group Threat and Regional Change in Attitudes toward African-Americans.American Journal of Sociology,102(3),816-860.
  46. Rokeach, Milton(ed.)(1960).The Open and Closed Mind.New York:Basic Books.
  47. Schlueter, Elmar,Scheepers, Peer(2010).The Relationship between Outgroup Size and Anti-Group Attitudes: A Theoretical Synthesis and Empirical Test of Group Threat and Intergroup Contact Theory.Social Science Research,39(2),285-295.
  48. Semyonov, Moshe,Rajiman, Rebeca,Tov, Anat Yom,Schmidt, Peter(2004).Population Size, Perceived Threat and Exclusion: A Multiple Indicator Analysis of Attitudes toward Foreigners in Germany.Social Science Research,33(4),681-701.
  49. Sigelman, Lee,Welch, Susan(1993).The Contact Hypothesis Revisited: Interracial Contact and Positive Racial Attitudes.Social Forces,71(3),781-795.
  50. Stein, Robert M.,Post, Stephanie S.,Rinden, Allison L.(2000).Reconciling Context and Contact Effects on Racial Attitudes.Political Research Quarterly,53(2),285-303.
  51. Strabac, Zan,Listhaug, Ola(2008).Anti-Muslim Prejudice in Europe: A Multilevel Analysis of Survey Data from 30 Countries.Social Science Research,37(1),268-286.
  52. Taylor, Marylee(1998).How White Attitudes Vary with the Racial Composition of Local Populations: Number Count.American Sociology Research,63(4),512-535.
  53. Wachman, Alan M.(1994).Taiwan: National Identity and Democratization.Armonk, NY:M. E. Sharpe.
  54. Wagner, Ulrich,Christ, Oliver,Pettigrew, Thomas F.,Stellmacher, Jost,Wolf, Carina(2006).Prejudice and Minority Proposition: Contact Instead of Threat Effects.Social Psychology Quarterly,69(4),380-390.
  55. Welch, Susan,Sigelman, Lee(2000).Getting to Know You? Latino-Anglo Social Contact.Social Science Quarterly,81(1),67-83.
  56. Welch, Susan,Sigelman, Lee,Bledsoe, Timothy,Combs, Michael(2001).Race and Place: Race Relations in an American City.New York:Cambridge University Press.
  57. Welsh, Bridget,Chang, Alex(2015).Choosing China: Public Perceptions of 'China as a Model'.Journal of Contemporary China,24(93),442-456.
  58. Wu, Chung-li,Su, Xiao-chen,Tsui, Hsiao-chien(2014).Threats, Acceptance, and Ambivalence in Cooperation: The Image of China in Taiwan.East Asia,31(4),305-322.
  59. Wu, Yu-shan(2016).Heading towards Troubled Waters? The Impact of Taiwan's 2016 Elections on Cross-Strait Relations.American Journal of Chinese Studies,23(1),59-75.
  60. Wu, Yu-shan(2005).Taiwan's Domestic Politics and Cross-Strait Relations.The China Journal,53,35-60.
  61. Xie, Tao,Page, Benjamin I.(2010).Americans and the Rise of China as a World Power.Journal of Contemporary China,19(65),479-501.
  62. Zhu, Jiang-nan,Lu, Jie(2013).One Rising China, Multiple Interpretations: China's 60th Anniversary Celebration through the Lens of the World's Printed Media.Journal of Contemporary China,22(84),1067-1088.
Times Cited
  1. Chia-chou Wang(2019).A Path to Critical Citizenship? Evidence from a Panel Study among Chinese Students Studying in Taiwan.Taiwan Journal of Democracy,15(2),57-85.
  2. 關弘昌(2018)。臺灣青年世代統獨與兩岸經貿交流態度之探索。遠景基金會季刊,19(2),1-40。