Translated Titles

Tastes Great, Less Filling? An Evaluation of Public-Private Collaboration in the Payment System of Taiwan's National Health Insurance (NHI)




王千文(Chian-Wen Wang);陳敦源(Don-Yun Chen)

Key Words

公私協力 ; 循證的公共管理 ; 總額支付制度 ; 組織構型 ; 成效評估 ; Public-Private Partnerships ; Evidence-based Public Management ; Organizational Frames (4Fs) ; Global Budget Payment System ; Evaluation



Volume or Term/Year and Month of Publication

42期(2012 / 03 / 01)

Page #

99 - 137

Content Language


Chinese Abstract

近年公私部門協力關係的建立,成為政府整合服務輸送資源、滿足民眾需求的新興治理模式,然此模式是否真能有效達成政策目標,實令人好奇。對於公私協力執行成效的評估,國外已有研究討論,反觀國內相關的評估文獻卻屈指可數,基此,本研究將以執行成效評估的角度出發,以「循證的公共管理」(evidence-based public management)思維,評估健保局總額支付制度下公私協力的執行成效,藉此驗證何種因素對於公私協力成效具有影響。本文首先透過文獻檢閱,歸結過去研究所提出的執行成功要件,並建構一套評估指標系統,以總額支付委員會的124位委員進行面對面問卷訪問調查;本文發現:首先,不論健保局內部運作或醫事團體內部自主管理,保持上下與平行單位間暢通的溝通管道,將有助於協力執行的成效。再者,健保局內部點值監控的擬定,醫事團體內部專業審查人員的推派及相互監督機制的發揮等,亦會影響協力執行的成效。最後,本文針對成效評估結果,於末了提出三項政策建議:其一,健保局內部組織運作的調整、其二、強化醫事團體的自主管理、以及其三、委員會權利與義務的清楚界定等,提供政府部門在推行總額支付制度改革作為時之參考。

English Abstract

In recent years, building public-private partnership (PPP) is the popular way to satisfy citizen demands through delivering government services Compared with other countries' experiences, there has been a problem of lacking systematic evaluations of various PPP applications in Taiwan. The purpose of this study is to utilize survey technique to evaluate the Global Budget Payment System of the Taiwanese National Health Insurance (NHI). First, an evaluating scheme is established from existing literatures. Second, the members of the Global Budget Payment Committee are face-to-face interviewed to evaluate the PPP. The eighty out of 124 members were responded and the response rate is around 65%.This research finds that the structural factors have positive influence on the effectiveness of PPP for both governments and medical associations. And, the symbolic dimension of public organization has a positive impact on the effectiveness of the partnership. Also, the dentist and Chinese medicine participants evaluate the partnerships better than those in hospitals and local clinics sections. However, the members from the southern section of the payment system have a lower evaluation of the partnership. Based on the above findings, this research concludes with three policy suggestions: some adjustments of internal operation in Bureau of National Health Insurance, increasing the autonomy of medical groups to manage their professional operations, and redefining and balancing rights and obligation of the Global Budget Payment Systems Committees.

Topic Category 社會科學 > 政治學
  1. 朱鎮明(2005)。政策網絡中協力關係的成效:理論性的探討。公共行政學報,17,113-158。
  2. 李柏諭(2005)。公私協力與社區治理的理論與實務:我國社區大學與政府經驗。公共行政學報,16,59-106。
  3. 莊文忠(2008)。績效衡量與指標設計:方法論上的討論。公共行政學報,29,61-92。
  4. 陳恆鈞、張國偉(2006)。組織協力與組織績效之研究:以雲林縣蔬菜產銷班為例。公共行政學報,19,41-52。
  5. 蔡秀涓(2004)。公務人員組織信任模型之建構:以台北市政府為例。人文及社會科學集刊,16(2),241-279。
  6. Simon, H. A. (1946). The proverbs of administration. Public Administration Review, 6(1), 53-67.
  7. The National Council for Public Private Partnerships. (2008). How PPPs work. Retrieved December 28, 2008, from http://ncppp.org/howpart/index.shtml#define.
  8. Alexander, E. R.(1998).A structuration theory of interorganizational coordination: Cases in environmental management.International Journal of Organizational Analysis,6(4),334-355.
  9. Alexander, J. A.,Comfort, M. E.,Weiner, B. J.(1998).Governance in public-private community health partnerships: A survey of the community care network demonstration sites.Nonprofit Management & Leadership,8(4),311-332.
  10. Allison, G.(1971).Essence of decision: Explaining the cuban missile crisis.Boston, MA:Little-Brown.
  11. Alter, C.,Hage, J.(1993).Organizations working together.Newbury. Park, Calif:Sage.
  12. Altman S. H.(Ed.),Reinhardt, U. E.(Ed.)(1996).Strategic choice for a changing health care system.Chicago, IL:Chicago Health Administration Press.
  13. Bailey, N.(1994).Towards a research agenda for public-private partnerships in the 1990s.Local Economy,6(4),292-305.
  14. Bardach, E.(1977).The implementation game cambridge.Cambridge, MA:MIT Press.
  15. Barr, D. A.(2007).A research protocol to evaluate the effectiveness of public-private partnerships as a means to improve health and welfare systems worldwide.American Journal o Public Health,97(1),19-25.
  16. Bazzoli, G. J.,Stein, R.,Alexander, J. A.,Conrad, D. A.,Sofaer, S.,Shortel, S. M.(1997).Public-private collaboration in health and human service delivery: evidence from community partnership.The Milbank Quarterly,75(4),533-561.
  17. Bennet, R. J.,Krebs, G.(1994).Economic development partnerships: An analysis of policy networks in the EC-LEDA local employment development strategies'.Regional Studies,28(2),119-140.
  18. Berman, E. M.(2006).Performance and productivity in public and nonprofit organizations.Armonk, N.Y.:M. E. Sharpe, Inc..
  19. Bing, L.,Akintoye, A.,Edwards, P. J.,Hardcastle, C.(2005).Critical success factors for PPP/PFI projects in the UK construction industry.Construction Management and Economics,23(5),459-471.
  20. Bolman, L. G.,Deal, T. E.(2003).Reframing organization: Artistry, choice and leadership.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
  21. Bolman, L. G.,Deal, T. E.(1991).Leadership and management effectiveness: A multiframe, multi-sector analysis.Human Resource Management,30(4),509-534.
  22. Bovaird, T.(2005).Public governance: Balancing stakeholder power in a network society.International Review of Administrative Sciences,71(2),217-228.
  23. Bromley, D.(Ed.)(1992).Making the commons work: Theory, practice and policy.San Francisco, CA:Institute for Contemporary Studies.
  24. Bryson, J. M.,Crosby, B.(1992).Leadership for the common good.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
  25. Burchardi, H.,Schuster, H. P.,Zielmann, S.(1994).Cost containment: Europe. Germany.New Horizons,2,364-374.
  26. Burger, J.(Ed.),Ostrom, E.(Ed.),Norgaard, R. B.(Ed.),Policansky, D.(Ed.)(2001).Protecting the commons: A framework for resource management in the Americas.Washington, DC:Island Press.
  27. Buse, K.,Waxman, A.(2001).Public-private health partnership: A strategy for WHO.Bull World Health Org,79,748-754.
  28. Culyer, A. J.(1989).Cost containment in Europe.Health Care Financing Review,Annual Supplement,21-32.
  29. Eastaugh, S. R.(2000).National healthcare spending and fiscal control: Comparisons among 15 Countries.Hospital Topics,78(4),9-13.
  30. Farazmand, A.(Ed.)(2004).Sound Governance: Policy and Administration Innovations.London:Westport.
  31. Farazmand, A.(Ed.)(2004).Sound governance: Policy and administrative innovations.London:Westport.
  32. Gray, B.(1989).Collaborating: Finding common ground for multiparty problems.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
  33. Hall, R. H.,Tolbert, P. S.(2005).Organizations: Structure, processes, and outcomes.Eaglewood Cliffs, N.J.:Prentice Hall.
  34. Hall, R.,Clark, J. P.,Giordano, P. C.,Johnson, P. V.,Roekel, M. V.(1977).Patterns of interorganisational relationships.Administrative Science Quarterly,22,456-474.
  35. Hardin, G.(1968).The tragedy of the commons.Science,162,1243-48.
  36. Hewison, A.(2004).Evidence-based management in the NHS: Is it possible?.Journal of Health Organization and Management,18(5),336-348.
  37. Hurley, J.,Card, R.(1996).Global physician budgets as common-property resources: Some implications for physicians and medical association.Canadian Medical Association Journal,154,1161-1168.
  38. Jack, M.,Phillips, R.(1993).Public-private partnership organizations in health care: Cooperative strategies and models.Hospital & Health Services Administration,38(3),387-400.
  39. Jones, G. R.(2001).Organizational theory: Text and cases.N.J.:Prentice Hall.
  40. Kleingeld, A.,Tuijl, H. V.,Algera, J. A.(2004).Participation in the design of performance management systems: A quasi-experimental field study.Journal of Organizational Behavior,25(7),831-851.
  41. Kooiman, J.(Ed.)(1993).Modern governance: New government-society interactions.London:Sage.
  42. Mattessich, P.,Monsey, B.(1992).Collaboration: What makes it work.Saint Paul, MN:Amherst H. Wilder Foundation.
  43. McGregor, M. M. D.(1989).Technology and the allocation of resources.New England Journal of Medicine,320,118-120.
  44. Meier, K. J, ,O'' Toole, L. J.(2001).Managerial strategy and behavior in networks: A model with evidence from U. S. public education.Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,11(1),274-291.
  45. Meier, K. J, ,O'' Toole, L. J.(2009).The proverbs of new public management: Lessons from an evidence-based research agenda.The American Review of Public Administration,39(1),4-22.
  46. Meyer, M. W.(2002).Rethinking performance measurement: Beyond the balanced scorecard.Cambridge:Cambridge University Press.
  47. Morgan, G.(1986).Images of organization.Beverly Hills, CA:Sage.
  48. Moynihan, D. P.(2005).Goal-based learning and the future of performance management.Public Administration Review,65(2),203-216.
  49. OECD(1990).Partnerships in rural development.Paris:OECD.
  50. Osborne, S.(2000).Public private partnerships: Theory and practice in international perspective.New York, NY:Routledge.
  51. Ostrom, E.(1990).Governing the commons: The evolution of institutions for collective action.New York, NY:Cambridge University Press.
  52. O''Toole, L. J.(1988).Strategies for intergovernmental management: Implementing programs in interorganizational networks.International Journal of Public Administration,11(4),417-441.
  53. O''Toole, L. J.,Montjoy, R. S.(1984).Inter-organizational policy implementation: A theoretical perspective.Public Administration Review,44(6),491-503.
  54. Perrow, C.(1986).Complex organizations: A critical essay.New York:Random House.
  55. Prior, D.(1996).Working the network: Local authority strategies in the reticulated local state.Local Government Studies,22(2),92-103.
  56. Quinn, R. E.(1988).Beyond rational management.San Francisco, CA:Jossey-Bass.
  57. Robbins, S. P.(2005).Organizational Behavior.Eaglewood Cliffs, N.J.:Pearson Prentice Hall.
  58. Rogers, D. L.,Whettern, D. A.,Halport, B. P.,Mulford, C. L.(1982).Interorganisational coordination.Ames, Iowa:Iowa State University Press.
  59. Sadao, K. C.,Robinson, N. B.(2002).Interagency systems development and evaluation in the pacific islands: A Process model for rural communities.Infants and Young Children,15(1),69-84.
  60. Sagalyn, L. B.(2007).Public/private development: Lessons from history, research, and practice.Journal of the American Planning Association,73(1),7-22.
  61. Sanderson, I.(2002).Evaluation policy learning and evidence-based policy making.Public Administration,80(1),1-22.
  62. Scheberle, D.(1997).Federalism and environmental policy: Trust and the politics of implementation.Washington, D.C.:Georgetown University Press.
  63. Schmitter, P.(1974).Still the century of corporatism.Review of Politics,36(1),35-131.
  64. Scott, W. R.(1981).Organizations: Rational, natural and open systems.Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice-Hall.
  65. Skelcher, C. M.,Lowndes, A.,Nanton, V. P.(1996).Community networks in urban regeneration: It all depends who you know...!.Bristol, UK:Policy Press.
  66. Trafford, S.,Proctor, T.(2006).Successful joint venture partnerships: Public-private partnerships.The International Journal of Public Sector Management,19(2),117-129.
  67. Webb, A.(1991).Co-ordination: A problem in public sector management.Policy and Politic,19(4),229-241.
  68. Weimer, D. L.(2007).Medical governance: Are we ready to prescribe?.Journal of Policy Analysis and Management,26(2),217-239.
  69. Wolfe, P. R.,Moran, D. W.(1993).Global budgeting in the OECD Countries.Health Care Financing Review,14(3),55-76.
  70. 丁仁方(1999)。威權統合主義:理論、發展、與轉型。台北:時英。
  71. 王文良、盧一帆、張宏哲、劉安琪(2006)。利用 PZB 與 FAHP 於養護機構服務品質評估之研究。健康管理學刊,4(1),103-120。
  72. 白裕彬、黃月桂、王惠玄(2002)。行政院衛生署委託研究報告行政院衛生署委託研究報告,台北市:行政院衛生署。
  73. 江明修編(2002)。非營利管理。台北:智勝。
  74. 吳重慶(2001)。醫療管理的省思(三)總額預算制度下醫療產業的因應之道。台灣醫界,44(7),55。
  75. 吳濟華(1994)。推動民間參與都市發展:公私部門協力策略之探討。台灣經濟,208,1-15。
  76. 李玉春(2005)。總額支付制度之規劃理念。台灣牙醫界,24(12),45-52。
  77. 李宗勳(2002)。政府業務委外經營之理論、策略與經驗。台北:智勝。
  78. 李長晏(2004)。全球化治理:地方政府跨區域合作分析。研考雙月刊,28(5),55-65。
  79. 林惠玲、陳正倉(2007)。應用統計學。台北:雙葉。
  80. 林震岩(2006)。多變量分析:SPSS 的操作與應用。台北:智勝。
  81. 施桂雲(2001)。彰化,私立大葉大學事業經營研究所。
  82. 徐正光譯、黃順二譯、Rosenberg, Morris(1989)。調查分析的邏輯。台北:黎明。
  83. 張瓊玲、張力亞(2005)。政府業務委外經營管理及運作過程之研究:以台北市政府社會局為例。華岡社科學報,19,31-60。
  84. 陳俊川(2004)。彰化,私立大葉大學事業經營研究所。
  85. 陳恆鈞(2002)。治理互賴與政策執行。台北:商鼎。
  86. 陳敦源、張世杰(2010)。公私協立夥伴關係的弔詭。文官制度季刊,2(3),17-71。
  87. 陳順義(2002)。嘉義,國立中正大學社會福利學系。
  88. 彭文賢(2001)。組織結構。台北:三民。
  89. 黃榮護編(2000)。公共管理。台北:商鼎。
  90. 楊志良(2003)。健康保險。台北:巨流。
  91. 楊漢湶(1997)。全民健康保險總額支付制度之實施背景及推展。台灣醫界,40(7),10-12。
  92. 鄭錫鍇(1999)。台北,國立政治大學公共行政研究所。
  93. 盧偉斯(1996)。台北,國立政治大學公共行政系。
  94. 盧瑞芬、謝啟瑞(2000)。醫療經濟學。台北:學富。
  95. 羅紀琼(2006)。醫院總額支付對資源分配的影響初探。全民健保總額支付的實施及其影響研討會,台北:
  96. 蘇鴻輝(2006)。,未出版
Times Cited
  1. 王光旭(2009)。決策的社會鑲嵌性及其影響:台灣中醫及牙醫健保總額支付委員會決策機制之分析。政治大學公共行政研究所學位論文。2009。1-297。
  2. 陳美如(2013)。花東線鐵路林榮車站復站之研究:協力治理觀點。中興大學國家政策與公共事務研究所學位論文。2013。1-225。
  3. 羅伍娉(2014)。從羅爾斯正義原則對全民健保總額支付制度之觀察。成功大學法律學系學位論文。2014。1-180。
  4. 吳虹文(2014)。客家商圈公私協力運作之研究-以龍潭鄉龍元宮商圈為例。中央大學客家研究碩士在職專班學位論文。2014。1-262。
  5. 金祈綉(2014)。地方政府與社會企業協力關係之研究─以新北市社會重建中心為例。臺北大學公共行政暨政策學系學位論文。2014。1-275。
  6. 羅瓊雲(2015)。整合照護計畫政策執行與評估:以中區某個案醫院為例。中正大學政治學系學位論文。2015。1-145。