Title

“美國軍事情報密檔”中的史迪威報告

Translated Titles

Joseph W. Stilwell's View-Abstracted from U.S. Military Intelligence Reports

DOI

10.7084/LIS.200505.0047

Authors

王湘(Hsiang Wang)

Key Words

史迪威 ; 蔣介石 ; Joseph W. Stilwell ; Chiang Kai-shek

PublicationName

語文與國際研究

Volume or Term/Year and Month of Publication

2期(2005 / 05 / 01)

Page #

47 - 66

Content Language

繁體中文

Chinese Abstract

史迪威是影響二次大戰後中美關係的關鍵人物之一,對中國軍隊之組織結構、成員素質、訓練方式等下過踏實的研究工夫。同時對中國人的民族性和習俗慣性,中國人的思考邏輯和行為模式有相當程度的瞭解和熟悉。擔任駐華武官四年,史氏撰寫了此一時期大部分之「密檔」報告,其對情勢之分析與研判,內容精闢,頗得其所屬部門之長官讚賞。但對中國人及中國當時的政治人物-尤以對蔣介石-則有不少曲解偏頗與嘲諷批判。史氏此種見解或已為其日後與蔣氏之不歡而散,埋下伏筆。本文就史氏報告中明顯偏執之部分予以評析,期能釐清現代史中之中美關係的某些疑惑。

English Abstract

This study focuses on Joseph W. Stilwel1's reports to U.S. War Department in the period of 1935 to 1939. Stilwell's evaluation and prediction in his reports has some unbelievable high lights as well as some prejudicial criticisms to Chinese people and to some political figures especially to Marshal Chiang Kai-shek. This study collects all of Stilwell's reports and points the evidence of his prejudice in his own writings. It is hopeful that this study could help to clear ax ay some suspicions in the modem Chinese history.

Topic Category 人文學 > 語言學
人文學 > 外國文學
Reference
  1. 美國軍事情報|美國國務院關於中國部份的中心機密檔案。美國大學出版公司。
  2. (1927).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,5,737.
  3. (1927).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,5,738.
  4. (1927).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,5,739.
  5. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9446),421-422.
  6. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9471),466.
  7. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9471),467.
  8. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9471),468.
  9. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9471),469.
  10. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9491),474-475.
  11. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9494),477.
  12. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9499),485.
  13. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9501),493、495.
  14. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9501),495.
  15. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9501),496.
  16. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,12(9329),420.
  17. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,13(9271),413-415.
  18. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,13(9310),432.
  19. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9329),420.
  20. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9353),442.
  21. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9423),472.
  22. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9423),474.
  23. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9482),531.
  24. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9482),532-533.
  25. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9482),534.
  26. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9482),535-536.
  27. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9489),542.
  28. (1936).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9493),551.
  29. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10,585.
  30. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10,588.
  31. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9510),500.
  32. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9579),551.
  33. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9583),556.
  34. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9583),557-558.
  35. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9583),562.
  36. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,10(9588),564.
  37. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2,692-693.
  38. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9514),585.
  39. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9516),593-594.
  40. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9528),601.
  41. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9528),602.
  42. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9539),631-632.
  43. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9539),634.
  44. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9580),673-674.
  45. (1937).USMIR, China, 1911-1941,2(9601),697.
  46. Barbara W. Tuchman(1972).Stilwell and the American Experience in China, 1911-1945.New York, N.Y.:Bantam Books.
  47. Kesaris, Paul.(Ed.)(1983).U.S. Military Intelligence Reports, China, 1911-1941,5,742.
  48. Kesaris, Paul.(Ed.)(1983).U.S. Military Intelligence Reports, China, 1911-1941,5,743.
  49. 李宗仁口述、唐德剛撰寫。李宗仁回憶錄
  50. 梁敬錞。史迪威事件
  51. 梁敬錞(1971)。史迪威事件。台北:台灣商務印書館。
  52. 陳存恭.從美國軍事情報探討安內攘外政策.
  53. 傅虹霖(1989)。張學良與西安事變,286。
  54. 楊日旭(1988).現代中國軍事史評論.高雄:國立中山大學中山學術研究所.
  55. 楊日旭(1987)。現代中國軍事史評論。國立中山大學中山學術研究所、國防部史政編譯局。