妖嬈若是：當代中國大陸「妖」的山寨性／別模組化展現

Flamboyantly Yao: Shanzhai Gender/Sexual Modularization among Contemporary Chinese Yaos

林純德(Dennis Chwen-der Lin)

《中外文學》 49卷4期 (2020/12) Pp. 67-124

https://doi.org/10.6637/CWLQ.202012_49(4).0004

摘要

二十一世紀初急速後工業化的中國大陸都會城市的邊緣窘蹙地區聚集大量農村剩餘勞動人口及弱勢底層民眾，其中有一群生理男性相繼以扮女裝的「妖」賣淫方式謀生。就在此一妖群體興起的時空裡，中國大陸同運積極打造政治正確的性／別主體性，以便對內建立中國家庭主義特色的同性戀正典化，對外與以西方為中心的全球LGBT運動接軌。換言之，正當在地同運戮力向上提昇之際，弔詭的是，底層賣淫的妖群體卻是逆勢而行，向下探底，持續磨礪出一種無視性／別文明化與進步性的頑強淫鄙姿態，並以其山寨性／別模組化展現惑亂了在地關乎西方現代性／別身分認同政治的知識中介及各就其位的性／別主體打造工程。本文採取結合深度訪談及參與觀察的民族誌研究方法，一探當代中國大陸妖的山寨性／別模組化展現及其惑亂效應。

關鍵字

妖 ； 性／別模組化 ； 山寨 ； 賣淫 ； 中介

並列摘要

Since the 2000s, there has been rapid post-industrialization in Mainland China, leading to numerous rural migrants and disadvantaged people gathering in the depressed areas of metropolitan cities. Among them are an increasing number of ＂yaos,＂ that is, people who make a living by male-to-female cross-dressing prostitution. Meanwhile, the emergence of the yao community is met with Chinese local LGBT activism's desire to align with the West-centered global LBGT movement. This is done through the mediation of gender/sexual identity politics in its attempt to forge a local homonormativity characterized by Chinese familism. In face of the ascending global respectability of Chinese LGBT activism, local yaos have persisted in their vulgarity, lewdness, and backwardness at the bottom of the heap. Employing an ethnographic research approach which combines in-depth interviews and participant observations, this essay theorizes this everyday tactic of contemporary Chinese yaos as ＂shanzhai gender/sexual modularization,＂ exploring how these abjected subjects negotiate their prostitution practices and trouble the gentrified local LGBT activism.

並列關鍵字

yao ； gender/sexual modularization ； shanzhai ； prostitution ； mediation

參考文獻

趙彥寧（Chao, Yenning）。2008。〈往生送死、親屬倫理與同志友誼：老T搬家續探〉“Wangsheng songsi qinshu lunli yu tongzhi youyi: Laoti banjia xutan” [Death Rituals, Kinship Ethics and Queer Friendship: Elderly Lesbian Tomboys in Taiwan]《文化研究》Router: A Journal of Cultural Studies 6: 153-94。

Cai, Yong, et al. 2016. “Prevalence and associated factors of condomless receptive anal intercourse with male clients among transgender women sex workers in Shenyang, China.” Journal of the International AIDS Society 19.3 Suppl 2: 20800.

卜長莉（Bu, Changli）。2009。《社會資本與東北振興》Shehui ziben yu dongbei zhenxing [Social Capital and the Revitalization of Northeast China]。北京：社會科學文獻出版社 [Beijing: Social Sciences Academic Press ]。

小明雄（Xiaomingxiong）。1997。《中國同性愛史錄》Zhongguo tongxingai shilu [History of Homosexuality in China]。香港：粉紅三角出版社 [Hong Kong: Rosa Winkel Press]。

北京愛知行研究所（Beijing Aizhixing Institute of Health Education）。2009。〈北京市跨性別性服務者現狀調查研究報告〉“Beijing shi kuaxingbie xingfuwuzhe xianzhuang diaocha yianjiu baogao” [Research Report Concerning Transgender Sex Workers’ Current Situation in Beijing City]。北京：北京愛知行研究所 [Beijing: Beijing Aizhixing Institute of Health Education]。