契約自由、民主政治與國家責任：格林對19世紀英國勞動立法過程中的階級代表課題之反思

Freedom of Contract, Democratic Politics and State Duty: Green's Critical Reflection on the Class Representation Issue in the 19th Century British Labour Legislation Movement

劉佳昊(Jia-hau Liu)

《人文及社會科學集刊》 32卷3期 (2020/09) Pp. 451-487

摘要

始自亞里斯多德而至社會契約論，西方契約學說歷經演變，迄於18世紀孕育國家不得任意干涉個人契約自由之原則。惟當產業革命繼起，勞雇雙方的契約不平等現象日益加劇。值此際，格林即藉批駁社會契約論與個人主義式的自由觀，開展了一套融貫個人自由、社群共善和政府干預等觀念之學說，為其積極鼓吹立法改革之基礎。而為闡述格林學說思想的實踐意義，本文即從19世紀英國勞動立法過程論起，敘明政黨政治的階級代表問題，何以成為格林開展其立論的關鍵因素之一。而就勞動立法議題來說，格林最終所促進的，乃是一套結合契約正義與國家責任思想的大眾民主論述。

關鍵字

格林 ； 契約自由 ； 國家干預 ； 政黨政治 ； 大眾民主

並列摘要

From Aristotle to social contract theory, contract doctrine has been through transformations, and by the 18th century, it had developed the principle that the state should not interfere with individual contract freedom. As the Industrial Revolution emerged, however, the unequal contract conditions between employees and employers had become worse. In order to found his call for legal reformation of these unequal conditions on a solid base, Green criticised social contract theory and the individualist conception of contractual freedom and constructed an alternative theory consisting of individual freedom, common goods and government intervention. The present article aims to expound the practical significance of Green's theoretical works , and accordingly, it will explicate how the class representation issue in the 19th century British Labour Legislation movement prompted Green to reconstruct the theorem of liberalism and provide a theory for the reformation. What Green thus established is a popular democratic theory with a focus on contractual justice and state duty.

並列關鍵字

Green ； freedom of contract ； state interference ； party politics ； popular democracy

參考文獻

陳建綱 2015〈休謨是契約論者嗎？對高提也的“David Hume, Contractarian”之批判性反思〉，《政治與社會哲學評論》55: 1-49。(Chen, Brian Chien-kang, 2015, “Is Hume a Contractarian? A Critical Reflection on David Gauthier’s “David Hume, Contractarian”,” SOCIETAS: A Journal for Philosophical Study of Public Affairs 55: 1-49.)

陳聰富 2003〈契約自由之限制：國家政策或契約正義？〉，《國立臺灣大學法學論叢》32(1): 119-164。(Chen, Tsung-fu, 2003, “Restraints on Freedom of Contract: State’s Policy or Contractual Justice,” National Taiwan University Law Journal 32(1): 119-164.)

劉佳昊 2015〈論格林的共善概念及其倫理政治思想〉，《政治與社會哲學評論》55: 107-161。(Liu, Jia-hau, 2015, “On Green’s Idea of Common Good and Ethical Politics,” SOCIETAS: A Journal for Philosophical Study of Public Affairs 55: 107-161.)

Arblaster, Anthony 1984 The Rise and Decline of Western Liberalism. Oxford: Blackwell.

Atiyah, Patrick S. 1979 The Rise and Fall of Freedom of Contract. Oxford: Clarendon Press.