選舉制度與族群政治：以新竹縣立法委員選區劃分為例

The Electoral System and Ethnic Politics: The Case of Legislative Redistricting in Hsinchu County

王保鍵(Wang, Pao-Chien)

《選舉研究》 27卷2期 (2020/11) Pp. 1-48

https://doi.org/10.6612/tjes.202011_27(2).0001

摘要

選舉制度之設計，涉及應選名額、投票制度、選區劃分等面向。我國立法委員自第7屆起改採單一選區兩票制，依《公職人員選舉罷免法》第35條所定「每10年重新檢討一次」，第10屆區域立法委員新竹縣應選名額由1席增加為2席。本文以文獻分析法，檢視投票制度、選區劃分相關制度設計，並運用投票行為理論，探討第10屆新竹縣立法委員選區劃分，獲致研究發現為：（1）新竹縣立法委員選區，劃分為「閩客混合選區」、「客家選區」，依苗栗縣選區劃分實作經驗，未來可能發展為閩南、客家各1席立法委員之族群政治平衡。（2）民進黨在新竹縣、苗栗縣之「閩客混合選區」，皆提名客家籍候選人，以「政黨及族群雙元認同」模式，爭取勝選。

關鍵字

單一選區多數決 ； 選區檢討劃分 ； 族群政治 ； 立法委員選舉

並列摘要

The design of the electoral system includes seats, voting, and electoral districts. From the Seventh Legislative Yuan, the single electoral district and the two-vote system have been adopted. According to Article 35 of the ＂Civil Servants Election and Recall Act,＂ seat distribution in the Legislative Yuan is reconsidered every 10 years to account for changes in the population. In 2020, the number of lawmakers' seats increased from 1 to 2 in Hsinchu County. This study employs a literature review to explore the voting system and legislative redistricting, as well as voting-behavior theory to discuss the issue of redrawing electoral districts in Hsinchu County. The findings include: (1) The legislators' electoral districts of Hsinchu County are divided into a ＂Minnan-Hakka mixed constituency＂ and a ＂Hakka constituency＂. Learning from Miaoli's experience, Hsinchu may have one Minnan lawmaker and one Hakka lawmaker. (2) In order to win the 2020 legislative election, the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) is employing a new campaign strategy, namely, the ＂dual identity of political parties and ethnic groups＂ model, via nominating Hakka candidates in Hsinchu and Miaoli.

並列關鍵字

first-past-the-post ； redistricting ； ethnic politics ； legislative elections

參考文獻

客家委員會，2017，《2016年度全國客家人口暨語言基礎資料調查研究》，新北市：客家委員會。(Hakka Affairs Council. 2017. “2016 Nian Du Chyuan Guo Ke Jia Ren Kou Ji Yu Yan Ji Chu Zih Liao Diao Cha Yan Jiou” [2016 National Hakka Population and Language Basic Data Survey Research]. New Taipei City: Hakka Affairs Council.)

范家豪，2019，〈立委蘇震清說明屏東縣立委選區劃分問題〉，屏東時報電子報：https://pingtungtimes.com.tw/?p=7171，檢索日期：2020年3月31日。(Fan, Jia-hao. 2019. “Li Wei Su Jhen Ching Shuo Shuo Ming Ping Dong Xian Li We Xuan Qu Hua Fen Wen Ti” [Su Chen-Ching explained the Pingtung County redistricting]. Pingtungtimes. https://pingtungtimes.com.tw/?p=7171 [accessed March 31, 2020].)

行政院主計總處，無日期，〈政府已經有戶籍登記資料、房地產登記管理制度及地政資訊系統，為何還需辦理人口及住宅普查〉，統計資訊網：https://www1.stat.gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=28552&ctNode=2722，檢索日期：2020年3月22日。(Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics, Executive Yuan. n. d. “Jheng Fu Yi Jing You Hu Ji Deng Ji Zih Liao, Fang Di Chan Deng Ji Guan Li Jhih Du Ji Di Jheng Zih Syun Si Tong, Wei He Hai Syu Ban Li Ren Kou Ji Jhu Jhai Pu Cha” [The Government Already Has Household Registration Information, Real Estate Registration Management System, and Land Administration Information System. Why Does it Need to Conduct a Population and Housing Census?]. National Statistics. https://www1.stat.gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=28552&ctNode=2722 [accessed March 22, 2020].)

莊旻靜，2018，〈監委下鄉視察，竹縣長陳情盼立委增席〉，中國時報：https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20180123004079-260405?chdtv，檢索日期：2020年1月6日。(Zhuang, Min-jing. 2018. “Jian Wei Sia Siang Shih Cha, Jhu Sian Jhang Chen Ching Pan Li Wei Zeng Si” [Hsinchu County Magistrate Ask for Increasing the Seat of Legislative Yuan When Control Yuan Comes]. Chinatimes.https://www.chinatimes.com/realtimenews/20180123004079-260405?chdtv [accessed January 6, 2020].)

莊淑媚、洪永泰，2011，〈特定政黨不認同：台灣地區民意調查中關於政黨認同的新測量工具〉，《選舉研究》，18(2)：1-29。(Chuang, Shu-mei and Hung, Yung-tai. 2011. “Te Ding Jheng Dang Bu Ren Tong: Tai Wan Di Chyu Min Yi Diao Cha Jhong Guan Yu Jheng Dang Ren Tong De Sin Tse Liang Gong Jyu” [A Study of Negative Identification against a Specific Party in Taiwan]. Journal of Electoral Studies 18(2): 1-29.)