高等教育普及化對於文憑訊號傳遞功能的影響：以賽局模型進行理論分析

The Influence of the Higher Education Universalization on the Signaling of Diplomas: Theoretical Analysis by Using a Game Model

柯朝斌(Chao-Pin Ko)

《教育科學研究期刊》 54卷2期 (2009/06) Pp. 107-133

摘要

本研究探討高等教育普及化如何透過文憑訊號傳遞的功能，影響求職者接受教育水準的選擇，以及雇主對於首次求職者薪資之決定。由於訊息不對稱，雇主無法在簽訂工作契約之前確實瞭解首次求職者的能力，因此，教育程度不僅是提升勞動力產出的要素，同時也是傳遞首次求職者能力訊息的一種訊號。透過賽局模型分析以及參數模擬，我們發現高等教育普及化使得文憑取得相對容易時，高能力者被迫選擇超過柏拉圖最適的教育水準，以求與低能力者做出區隔；當高等教育持續擴張造成文憑氾濫，此時的混同均衡會使雇主無法以文憑來辨別首次求職者能力，於是雇主給予社會新鮮人的薪資將減少，體系的均衡將偏離柏拉圖最適，甚至造成社會新鮮人總產出的下降，這是臺灣高等教育普及化的隱憂。

關鍵字

訊息不對稱 ； 訊號傳遞 ； 高等教育 ； 教育普及化

並列摘要

In this paper, we investigate how the higher education universalization affects the choice of the first-time job seeker and the employer through the signaling function of diploma. Because of the asymmetric information, the employer can’t understand the first-time job seeker’s ability absolutely before making a contract. Therefore, education is not only a factor to increase labor productivity, but also a signal to communicate the information of worker’s ability to the employer. By building a game model and using parameter simulation, we find that the job seeker with higher ability will overeducate to make the employer can separate higher ability first-time job seekers from lower ability ones when the expansion of higher education makes it easy to acquire a diploma. Once overabundant diploma due to the expansion of higher education universalization makes the employer can not discriminate higher ability candidates from lower ability ones, the employer reduces the salary of social freshman. Such phenomenon induces the equilibrium away from the Pareto optimality and decreases the total social production.

並列關鍵字

asymmetric information ； signaling ； higher education ； educational universalization

參考文獻

張德勝(2005)。台灣地區大學校院「學生評鑑教師教學」制度之研究。師大學報：教育類。50(2)，203-225。

2005新鮮人起薪大公開

2008企業招募新鮮人現況大調查

Billing, D.(2004).International comparisons and trends in external quality assurance of higher education: Commonality or diversity?.Higher Education.47(1),113-137.

Clark, B. R.(1983).The higher education system. Academic organization in cross-national perspective.LA:University of California Press.