認同、敘事、與行動：台灣1970年代黨外的歷史建構

Identity, Narrative, and Action: Anti-KMT Dissident Construction of History in 1970s Taiwan

蕭阿勤(A-Chin Hsiau)

《台灣社會學》 5期 (2003/06) Pp. 195-250

https://doi.org/10.6676/TS.2003.5.195

摘要

1970年代台灣的外交挫折與社會經濟變遷等因素，激發戰後世代的社會政治改革意識。當時反國民黨的「黨外」人士是這個戰後世代的重要組成份子。本文從「敘事認同」的理論取向，探討黨外的政治改革主張與其歷史敘事的辯證關係。本文從「非工具論的情境論或建構論」角度分析，指出黨外以一種基於中國民族主義的歷史敘事，將個人自我與社會、國家、民族聯繫起來，建構戰後世代的集體認同感，而此種歷史敘事及世代認同與其政治社會的改革行動密不可分。本文的結論指出：黨外成員以中國民族主義的歷史敘事來理解台灣的過去，尤其是台灣人抗日史，將他們原本被教化的中國民族／國家認同加以充實、具體化，然而因為其強調台灣鄉土歷史與文化而有助於美麗島事件後、八○年代初以降黨外的台灣意識、台灣民族主義的政治動員與文化建構。對台灣七○年代黨外的集體記憶重構與族群政治的關係，及其與八○年代以來台灣文化民族主義發展的歷史聯繫，本文提供一個具有理論意涵的分析理解。

關鍵字

認同 ； 敘事 ； 黨外 ； 世代 ； 民族主義

並列摘要

Throughout the 1970s, tang-wai -the name given to anti-KMT dissidents- were at the center of the Taiwanese postwar generation's response to the country's diplomatic failures, authoritarian rule, and economic inequalities. Using a narrative identity approach to political action, I analyze the dialectical relationship between tang-wai political reform efforts and a historical narrative. From non-instrumentalist situationalist and non-instrumentalist constructionist perspectives, I also argue that a Chinese nationalist narrative of history helped tang-wai to connect individuals with their society/ nation, and to form a sense of collective identity with other members of the postwar generation. My conclusion is that in the 1970s, the tang-wai substantiated their Chinese national identity by adopting a historical narrative to make sense of Taiwan's past, especially in terms of Taiwanese resistance to Japanese colonialism. Their rediscovery of this history contributed greatly to the political mobilization and cultural construction of Taiwanese nationalism that began in the 1980s. Here I attempt to establish a theoretical understanding of tang-wai reconstruction of a collective memory that incorporated ethnic politics in 1970s Taiwan and its impact on post-1980s nationalist politics.

並列關鍵字

identity ； narrative ； tang-wai ； generation ； nationalism

參考文獻

吳乃德(2000)。人的精神理念在歷史變革中的作用—美麗島事件和台灣民主化。台灣政治學刊。4，57-103。

鄭鴻生(2001)。青春之歌：追憶1970年代台灣左翼青年的一段如火年華。台北:聯經。

Abbott, Andrew(1992).From Causes to Events: Notes on Narrative Positivism.Sociological Methods & Research.20(4),428-455.

Arendt, Hannah(1998).The Human Condition.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.

Barker, Chris(2000).Cultural Studies: Theory and Practice.London:Sage.