學校組織中集體協商運作之研究－以北部六縣市國民中學為例

A Study of Collective Bargaining in School Organizations: The Example of Junior High Schools in Six Counties and Cities in Northern Taiwan

黃乃熒(Nai-Ying Whang) ； 曹芳齡(Fang-Ling Tsao)

《教育研究集刊》 49:2期 (2003/06) Pp. 63-96

https://doi.org/10.6910/BER.200306_(49-2).0003

摘要

本研究旨在了解提升國民中學集體協商成效的機制。鼓勵集體協商運作乃是教育改革的方向，其理想的目標，包括落實學校本位管理、維護利害關係人權益及促進學校目標的達成。但是在集體協商運作的過程中，會出現協商地位不對等、協商意見不易整合、無法進行理性協商、予人爭權奪利的印象及協商知能不足的困境，進而影響集體協商運作的成效。因此有必要對於解決集體協商困境的策略進行探討。為了達到本研究的目的，本研究採用調查研究法來蒐集資料，並運用分層比例叢集抽樣及立意取樣，在北部六縣市抽取40所國民中學，並發出867份問卷，有效回收問卷為587份，有效回收率為67.7%。然後以有效問卷進行統計考驗，並透過分析與討論，據以提出結論及建議。

關鍵字

學校組織 ； 集體協商 ； 國民中學

並列摘要

This study is to understand the mechanisms that facilitate the efficacy of collective bargaining in junior high schools. Promoting collective bargaining has been the trend in recent educational reforms in Taiwan. It is hoped that the implementation of school-based management, the protection of stakeholders' rights, and the achievement of school goals will be realized accordingly. The processes of collective bargaining, however, can easily produce such difficulties among stakeholders as unequalizing status, creating divergent opinions, stimulating irrational negotiations, causing power struggles, and bringing about deficits in negotiation knowledge, all of which lead to a lower quality of collective bargaining. With its focus on this problem, this study tries to devise strategies that can resolve the inherent difficulties in collective bargaining. It adopts an investigative approach to collect the data, administering 867 questionnaires from 40 junior high schools in six counties and cities in northern Taiwan by stratified proportional cluster sampling and purposive sampling. In total, 587 effective questionnaires comprise the basis of the statistical test, for an effective questionnaire ratio of 67.7%. Along with the statistical analysis, this study provides school members with some valuable conclusions and suggestions.

並列關鍵字

school organization ； collective bargaining ； junior high school

參考文獻

黃乃熒(2000)。學校行政瘋狂行為實際之探究：以國中教評會為例。教育研究集刊。47

Healy, J, J.(1965).Creative collective bargaining: Meeting today's challenges to labor-management relations..

Kassalow, E. M.(1969).Perspective on the upsurge of public employee unionism..Collective negotiation for public and professional employees.

Keane, W, G.(1996).Win/win or else'. Collective bargaining in an age of public discontent..

Kochan, T. A.,Katz, H. C.(1988).Collective bargaining and industrial relations: From theory to policy and practice.