預算支出目標調整之困難度對後續預算執行及預算績效之影響：以策略性溝通作為權變因素

The Effect of Difficult Adjustments in Budget Expenditure Goal on Budget Execution and Budgeting Performance: The Contingent Effect of Strategic Communication

盧正宗(Cheng-Tsung Lu) ； 祝道松(Dauw-Song Zhu)

《會計評論》 69期 (2019/07) Pp. 131-172

https://doi.org/10.6552/JOAR.201907_(69).0004

摘要

預算目標可能因應環境的變化而適時修正，因此管理當局必須當機立斷制定出目標調整決策。本研究以違反預期理論作為理論基礎，進一步探討在不同策略性溝通的權變效果下，預算支出目標調整之困難度與預算績效間是否存在其他中介變數（預算執行彈性、預算執行衝突）之影響。透過問卷調查方式取得國內區域級醫院的227位醫療部科主管之研究資料，實證結果發現：（1）在策略性溝通程度低的醫療組織中，預算支出目標調整之困難度經由負向影響預算執行彈性，進而才間接引發負向的預算績效。（2）在策略性溝通程度高的醫療組織中，預算支出目標調整之困難度經由負向降低預算執行衝突，進而才間接導致正向的預算績效。（3）預算支出目標之調整決策確實讓預算主管減少許多可動用之預算資源，同時增加預算流用之困難度。

關鍵字

違反預期理論 ； 預算目標調整 ； 預算執行彈性 ； 預算執行衝突

並列摘要

Budgeting goal may be revised in response to changes in the environment, so the management needs to make goal adjustment decisions to meet timeliness. Based on the theory of expectancy violation, this study explores the impact of mediating variables (budget executive flexibility and budget executive conflict) between difficult adjustments in budget expenditure goal and budgeting performance under the contingent effect of different strategic communication. Research data were obtained from 227 medical department supervisors in regional hospitals by questionnaires. Empirical results show that: (1) In the medical organizations with low strategic communication, difficult adjustments in budget expenditure goal negatively affects departmental supervisors' budget executive flexibility, which indirectly leads to negative budgeting performance. (2) In the medical organizations with high strategic communication, difficult adjustments in budget expenditure goal negatively reduces departmental supervisors' budget executive conflict, which indirectly leads to positive budgeting performance. (3) The budget goal adjustment decision indeed diminishes budgetary resources for medical department supervisors, and creates additional difficulty for budgetary transfers.

並列關鍵字

Expectancy violation theory ； Budget goal adjustment ； Budget executive flexibility ； Budget executive conflict

參考文獻

吳潔人 、 吳怡玟與郭年真 , 2018 , 低價值醫療之探討 , 台灣公共衛生雜誌 , 第 37 卷 (12月) : 602-613 • (Wu, C. J., Y. W. Wu, and R. N. Kuo. 2018. A review of low-value care. Taiwan Journal of Public Health 37 (December): 602-613.) (DOI: 10.6288/TJPH.201812_37(6).107088)

劉亞明 、 羅德芬與粘毓庭 , 2017 , 醫院退出市場因素之分析 , 台灣公共衛生雜誌 , 第 36 卷第 3 期 ( 9 月 ) : 273-286 • (Liu, Y. M., T. F. Lo, and Y. T. Nien. 2017. An empirical analysis of exits from the hospital market. Taiwan of Public 10.6288/TJPH201736106005) Journal Health 36 (September): 273-286.) (DOI:

汪秀玲 、 關皚麗與黃俊英 , 2010 , 醫院策略執行對醫師同理心之影響 : 跨層次分析 , 臺灣公共衛生雜誌 , 第 29 卷第 6 期 ( 12 月 ) : 487-502 。 (Wang, H. L., A. L. Kwan, and J. Y. Huang. 2010. The effect of hospital strategy implementation on physicians' empathy: A cross-level analysis. Taiwan Journal of Public Health 29 (December): 487-502.) (DOI: 10.6288/TJPH2010-29-06-02)

江家瑜 、 朱炫璉與黃勝堅 , 2019 , 特色醫療整合之合併綜效一以臺北市立聯合醫院為例 , 管理評論 , 第 38 卷 ( 1 月 ) : 103-104 。 ( Chiang , C. Y. , H. L. Chu, and S. J. Huang. 2019. Synergetic effects of integrating specialty healthcare: A case study of Taipei City Hospital. Management Review 38 (January): 103-104.) (DOI: 10.6656/MR.201901_38(1).CNI103)

盧正宗與張仲岳 , 2015 , 探討醫療組織誘因制度 、 權益公平認知對醫師工作績效之影響 － 以預算強調做為權變因素 , 會計評論 , 第 60 期 ( 1 月 ) : 73-109 • (Lu, C. T., and C. C. Y. Chang. 2015. The effect of hospital incentives and equity fairness perceptions on physicians' job performance: Budget emphasis as a contingent variable. Journal of Accounting Review 60 (January): 73-109. ) (DOI: 10.6552/JOAR.2015.60.3)