從查理周刊等攻擊事件思考移民社會中基本權保障之潛在問題

Rethinking Constitutional Rights in a Society of Immigration: A Discussion inspired by Charlie Hebdo Shooting

范秀羽(Hsiu-Yu Fan)

《東吳法律學報》 28卷1期 (2016/07) Pp. 151-183

摘要

2015 年1 月7 日法國查理週刊槍擊事件，引起多方關注，此事件於國內熟悉之憲法學自由權平等權區分架構下，屬於自由權衝突或是言論自由管制之問題，亦即查理週刊之言論自由（媒體自由）與穆斯林之宗教自由兩者間之衝突或是前者言論自由之管制問題。本文試圖將平等保障問題帶入憲法自由權利衝突之討論脈絡中，點出在關涉不同文化及精神自由之基本權利衝突時，應參酌憲法平等保障，將各權利主體之強弱勢置於所處之社會文化環境中進行討論。隨後本文藉由壓迫與歧視之多重交錯性觀點，重新以平等保障之角度理解法國查理週刊槍擊事件之爭議並檢視法國穆斯林之處境。最後，本文思考法律與國家公權力在此類事件之可能立場及角色為何。

關鍵字

查理週刊 ； 基本權利衝突 ； 諷刺（仇恨）言論 ； 平等保障

並列摘要

Charlie Hebdo Shooting on the 7^(th) of January 2015 has received massive attention throughout the world. Prevailing constitutional theories would see this incident as either conflicts between two fundamental rights: Charlie Hebdo's freedom of speech (freedom of press) to publish satirical work against Islam and Muslim and Muslims' freedom of religion, or simply restraints on freedom of the press. This Article seeks to bring into this discussion the concept of equal protection. To guarantee the safeguard of fundamental rights, it must be taken into account the vulnerable vis-a-vis advantaged position of each subject of rights in the particular socio-cultural context. Also, considering the plight of French Muslims, this Article re-examines Charlie Hebdo Shooting with the intersectionality of discrimination and oppression based on religion, race, immigration identity and social class. Finally this Article discusses the possible roles of the State and law in any situation similar to Charlie Hebdo.

並列關鍵字

Charlie Hebdo ； conflicts of fundamental rights ； satirical (hate) speech ； equal protection

參考文獻

吳庚(2014)。憲法理論與政府體制。作者自版。

吳宗謀(2015)。地產地消的〈起司與馬卡龍〉。台灣法學雜誌。264，31-32。

李建良(1997)。基本權利理論體系之構成及其思考層次。人文及社會科學集刊。9(1)，39-83。

(2000)。月旦法學雜誌別冊。

李惠宗(2001)。憲法要義。元照出版公司。