Bezoars are foreign that are formed by concretions of undigested food particles, masses of foreign bodies and undigested seeds and fibers of fruits that impact in the gastrointestinal tract, with the stomach being the most common site. They usually result in intestinal obstruction, ulcer formation, hemorrhage and perforation. Management of bezoars is usually surgical with fragmentation and milking it cephalad or caudad depending on its location and level of obstruction. A colonic bezoar causing bowel obstruction is a very rare occurrence. Experiencing it twice in a lifetime at the same location is even a rarer occurrence. We present a case of a recurrent colonic phytobezoar, secondary to habitual chewing and ingestion of betel nut fiber, which was successfully managed surgically. To the best of knowledge, a recurrent obstructing colonic bezoar related to betel nut chewing has never been reported before in literature.