崇禮與性善──清儒程瑤田義理思想探析

An Interpretation of Cheng Yao-tian's Philosophy

廖曉煒(Xiao-wei LIAO) ； 朱燕玲(Yan-ling ZHU)

《哲學與文化》 46卷6期 (2019/06) Pp. 141-154

摘要

本文以性善說及工夫論的討論為中心，梳理並評估程瑤田的義理思想。受時代思潮的影響，瑤田之學表現出鮮明的崇禮重實的特徵。程瑤田藉朱子學的概念框架來闡述其對性善說及工夫論的思考，不過其理論系統與朱子學預設了完全不同的形上學基礎，瑤田接受的是一自然主義的「氣一元論」，拒斥朱子學理氣二分、義理之性與氣質之性二分等觀念。瑤田的義理思想可方便地稱之為「被稀釋的」朱子學。

關鍵字

程瑤田 ； 性善 ； 被稀釋的朱子學

並列摘要

As a representative scholar during Qianlong and Jiaqing period of the Qing dynasty, Cheng Yao-tian's philosophy has a great effect on many scholars of that time, such as Ling Tingkan (凌廷堪), Jiao Xun (焦循) and so on. This paper will give an interpretation of Cheng Yao-tian's philosophy from three aspects. First, through analyzing Cheng's discourse, we can find the general characteristic of his philosophy: attach great importance to ritual. Second, although Cheng accept a naturalistic philosophy of Qi (氣), he gives a stronger interpretation of Mencius' theory of human nature than many scholars in Qing dynasty. Finally, Cheng uses many Zhu Xi's concepts to establish his philosophy, such as ＂the mind commands man's nature and feelings＂ (心統性情), but his philosophy and Zhu Xi's doctrine belongs to different philosophical paradigms. In a sense, we can regard Cheng' philosophy as a thin version of Zhu Xi's doctrine.

並列關鍵字

Cheng Yao-tian ； Human Nature is Good ； Zhu Xi's Doctrine

參考文獻

伊東貴之，《中國近世的思想典範》，臺北：臺大出版中心，2015。

朱永純，《毋欺錄》，收入《叢書集成續編（四一）》，臺北：新文豐出版公司，1989。

朱熹，《四書章句集註》，北京：中華書局，1983。

李明輝，《儒家與康德》，臺北：聯經出版事業公司，1990。

凌廷堪，《校禮堂文集》，北京：中華書局，1998。