停經後骨質疏鬆症中醫證型的實證文獻探討

Evidence Based Clinical Trial Articles Review Study Regarding to Syndrome Patterns Classification of Traditional Chinese Medicine on Postmenopausal Osteoporosis Syndrome

李采珍(Tsai-Jen Lee) ； 蔡金川(Chin-Chuan Tsai) ； 洪裕強(Yu-Chiang Hung)

《中醫藥雜誌》 27卷1期 (2016/06) Pp. e1-8

https://doi.org/10.3966/241139642016062701005

摘要

停經後骨質疏鬆症(postmenopausal osteoporosis，PMO) 是一種多面向致病因素的全身代謝性骨骼疾病，盛行率和發生率隨全球人口老化趨勢而上升。辨證論治是中醫臨床實踐的重要特色，中醫藥在PMO 的治療，也有幾千年的實務經驗，唯其相關證型在中醫界尚無共識。因此，本文藉由實證醫學精神及評分方法，探討2005 至2015 年內的中醫相關臨床試驗研究，結果顯示「骨質疏鬆症中醫證型」相關文獻搜尋共96 篇，排除動物實驗模式與針灸治療、中西結合治療、從臨床實踐中總結出來的自製中藥製劑之72 篇相關文獻，以及臨床個案報告14 篇後，篩選出PMO 中醫證型的實證文獻共10 篇。其中屬隨機對照臨床實驗研究文獻1 篇，病例對照研究文獻1 篇，病例研究文獻8 篇。上述PMO 實證文獻以腎陽虛證80% 最高，肝腎陰虛證70% 次之，脾腎陽虛證、及氣滯血瘀證皆60% 又次之，研究結論建議腎陽虛證、脾腎陽虛證、肝腎陰虛證、氣滯血瘀證等四型，可作為PMO 治療的主要證型。

關鍵字

停經後骨質疏鬆症 ； 中醫藥 ； 證型 ； 實證醫學

並列摘要

Female postmenopausal osteoporosis (PMO) is a multiple and complicated pathological change of systemic metabolic bone diseases. The incidence and prevalence of PMO is increasing with the aging population in the world. Pattern identification as the base for determining treatment has been playing a very important role in the clinical practice of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). There are thousands of years of clinical experience in the treatment of PMO with TCM. However, there is no consensus related to syndrome patterns of PMO among TCM practitioners to each other. In this present evidence based study, we survey the clinical trial articles during the year 2005-2015 in order to invertigating the syndrome patterns classification of TCM in postmenopausal osteoporosis syndrome. We found 96 articles related to TCM syndrome pattern of PMO from database. After excluding 72 relevant literature with animal model, acupuncture, integrated Chinese and western medicine, homemade herbs, or case report, we finally selected 10 evidenced based papers. There were one randomized clinical trial, one case control study and 8 case series literature. Our results showed that proportion of PMO would be 80% deficiency of Kidney-yang, 70% Yin-deficiency of both the Liver and Kidney, followed by 60% Yang-deficiency of both the Spleen and Kidney and 60% blood stasis due to Stagnancy of Qi. Therefore, we recommend that there are four main patterns, namely deficiency of Kidney-yang, Yin-deficiency of both the Liver and Kidney, Yang-deficiency of both the Spleen and Kidney and blood stasis due to Stagnancy of Qi on PMO.

並列關鍵字

Postmenopausal osteoporosis (PMO) ； syndrome patterns ； traditional Chinese medicine ； evidence based medicine

參考文獻

Riggs, BL,Melton, LJ(1986).Involutional osteoporosis.N. Engl. J. Med..314,1676-1686.

World Health Organization(2003).Prevention and management of osteoporosis.WHO Tech. Rep. Seri..921,1-164.

中華民國骨質疏鬆症學會(2015)。台灣成人骨質疏鬆症防治之共識及指引。桃園:

Shih, WT,Yang, YH,Chen, PC(2012).Prescription patterns of Chinese herbal products for osteoporosis in Taiwan: a populationbased study.Evid. Based Complement. Alternat. Med..2012,752837.

胡文龍(2010)。更年期障礙中醫典籍研究。臺北:行政院衛生署中醫藥委員。