古老的社會幽靈：陶希聖與王亞南的社會科學官僚論

透過陶希聖與王亞南在1920－1940年代對官僚主義的批判，本文探討國、共兩黨再革命理論所共有的思想淵源。陶希聖與王亞南批判官僚主義時所針對的，分別是20年代的國民革命以及40年代的共產革命。面對革命即將成功的希望，他們都以20年代興起的社會科學世界觀，運用「官僚」（bureaucracy）概念來涵攝各種深層的道德與社會問題，並明確指出革命不應只停留在政權更迭而已。本文既會把陶希聖與王亞南的著作，置諸1920－1940年代的特殊脈絡裏，細緻地分析他們的具體境況；同時也將從官僚主義的思想史切入，探討再革命理論在20世紀初的獨特吸引力以及困境。

關鍵字

陶希聖；王亞南；社會科學；官僚主義；再革命；國民革命；共產革命

並列摘要

This paper historicizes Tao Xisheng and Wang Yanan's critiques of bureaucratism and theories of further revolution. In contexts of the political culture from the 1920s to 1940s, the cases of Tao Xisheng and Wang Yanan reveal an unnoticed intellectual lineage shared by the Nationalist and Communist camps. Originally written in response to the Nationalist Revolution in 1920s and the Communist Revolution in 1940s, the anti-bureaucratic discourses of Tao and Wang shared a so-called social science discourse which emerged in the 1920s. Employing the concept of bureaucracy to encapsulate fundamental, and often moral, questions of society, they argued that revolutionaries should move further beyond the change of regimes. By contextualizing the works of Tao and Wang, this paper not only refines our understanding of the political culture of the 1920s and 1940s, but also sheds light on the appeal of the idea of further revolution, and its predicaments in the twentieth century.

並列關鍵字

Tao Xisheng ； Wang Yanan ； social science ； bureaucracy ； further revolution ； Nationalist Revolution ； Communist Revolution

參考文獻

毛澤東 1991　《毛澤東選集》。北京：人民出版社。（Mao, Zedong, 1991, Selected Works of Mao Zedong. Beijing: People’s Publishing House.）

Google Scholar

王汎森 2020　《啟蒙是連續的嗎？》。香港：香港城市大學出版社。（Wang, Fan-sen, 2020, A Discussion on the Continuity of the Enlightenment. Hong Kong: City University of Hong Kong Press.）

Google Scholar

王亞南 1931 〈封建制度論〉，《讀書雜誌》1(4- 5): 1- 47。（Wang, Yanan, 1931, “On the Feudal System,” Dushu Zazhi 1(4- 5): 1-47.）

Google Scholar

王亞南 1946 《社會科學新論》。福州：經濟科學出版社。（Wang, Yanan, 1946, New Discourse on Social Science. Fuzhou: Jingji Kexue Chubanshe.）

Google Scholar

王亞南 1947 〈中國官僚資本之理論的分析〉，《文匯叢刊》5: 41- 51。（Wang, Yanan, 1947, “A Theoretical Analysis of Bureaucratic Capital in China,” Wenhui Congkan 5: 41-51.）

Google Scholar

主題瀏覽