動態的臺海兩岸談判：雙層賽局與認知因素研究

Changing Negotiations between the Two Sides of the Taiwan Strait-Two-Level Game and Cognitive Factors Approaches

袁鶴齡(Hao-Lin Yuan) ； 沈燦宏(Tsan-Hung Shen)

《東吳政治學報》 32卷3期 (2014/09) Pp. 173-240

摘要

從1990年代初期兩岸政府重啟談判協商以來，彼此之間的談判互動已出現愈來愈頻繁的現象。雖然兩岸至今在主權上仍存有爭議，但在其他議題的協商上，卻也出現日漸增多的趨勢。為了理解兩岸談判中的複雜性，本文嘗試在Putnam「雙層賽局」（two-level game）的基礎之上，增列國家決策者個人認知因素（decision-maker cognitive factors）以擴展其分析框架，並依據戰略三角理論將兩岸談判區分成六個時期，以討論個別時期之間的差異。研究發現，在把個人認知因素結合談判曲線，形成從國際、國內到個人層次的動態分析途徑，更能解釋兩岸談判的發展歷程及其議題連結（issue linkage）的談判特性。

關鍵字

兩岸談判 ； 雙層賽局 ； 認知因素 ； 戰略三角 ； 議題連結

並列摘要

In the early 1990s, cross Taiwan Strait governments reopened the gate of negotiation. Since then, the debate of sovereignty still remains between the two sides, but the number of issues that both sides have continuously negotiated has increased. In order to understand the complication of cross-strait negotiations, we extend Putnam's two-level game framework to include cognitive factors of national decision-makers. This paper also intends to divide cross-strait negotiations into six periods on the basis of the strategic triangle theory, and distinguish differences among periods. The paper finds that cognitive factors combined with the negotiation curve shapes the dynamic approach from an international and domestic level to an individual level analysis. It has more explanatory power to explain the differences among six periods to understand the development of cross-strait negotiations. This paper also can distinguish the characteristics of issue linkage negotiations more easily.

並列關鍵字

cross-strait negotiation ； two-level game ； cognitive factors ； strategic triangle ； issue linkage

參考文獻

Adler, Emanuel(2005).Communitarian International Relations: The Epistemic Foundations of International Relations.New York:Routledge Press.

Bau, Tzong-Ho(1998).The Challenges to the Political Negotiation Across the Taiwan Strait.Political Science Review.6,385-398.

Bazerman, Max H.,Neale, Margaret A.(1992).Negotiating Rationally.New York:The Free Press.

Bernard, Phyllis E.(2009).Bring Soul to International Negotiation.Negotiation Journal.25(2),147-160.

Boudon, Raymond(1996).The 'Cognitivist Model': A Generalized 'Rational-Choice Model'.Rationality and Society.8(2),123-150.