歐洲聯盟對抗工作場所霸凌問題之努力：回顧與前瞻

Combating Workplace Bullying in the European Union: Retrospect and Prospect

焦興鎧(Cing-Kae Chiao)

《歐美研究》 51卷1期 (2021/03) Pp. 159-209

https://doi.org/10.7015/JEAS.202103_51(1).0004

摘要

本文目的是要對歐洲聯盟過去五十多年來，透過職業安全衛生法制之建構，對工作場所霸凌這類新興勞動問題加以因應之努力，做一全面回顧與檢視，並探究它制定對會員國具法律拘束力相關指令之可能性。除前言及結語外，全文共分三大部分。首先說明各類職場不法侵害，包括：就業歧視、性騷擾、暴力、侵及隱私及霸凌等問題興起之背景。其次以四個階段為期，分析它過去建構傳統職業安全衛生法制之各項努力，藉以導出嗣後開始正視人為因素在職場所產生各種負面影響之緣由。最後則探究對制定統一性指令之正反意見，並以國際勞工組織在2019年所通過之190號公約及美國之經驗，分析歐洲聯盟現有制度之優劣得失、引起爭議之處及可供我國啟示之經驗。

關鍵字

歐洲聯盟之職業安全衛生法制 ； 工作場所不法侵害 ； 職場霸凌 ； 工作場所騷擾 ； 職場暴力

並列摘要

The purpose of this paper is to offer an overall assessment of efforts made by the European Union in combating workplace bullying. It also examines whether it is possible to promulgate a binding directive for its Member States to solve this problem. The main contents of the paper are divided into four sections. Section One provides a general background about the development of psychosocial workplace hazards, such as discrimination, harassment, violence and bullying in the European Union. Sections Two traces various efforts made by the European Union in combating workplace bullying through the legal regime governing occupational safety and health matters. Section Three reviews the opinions supporting or opposing for the EU to enact related directives for its Member States. It also discusses the merits and shortcomings of the current EU system and examines what Taiwan can learn as it confronts this issue in the workplace.

並列關鍵字

occupational safety and health rules in the European Union (EU) ； workplace mistreatment ； workplace bullying ； harassment in the workplace ； workplace violence

參考文獻

王玉葉 (2000)。〈歐洲聯盟之補助原則〉，《歐美研究》，30, 2: 1-30。(Wang, Y.-Y. [2000]. The principle of subsidiarity in the European Union. EurAmerica, 30, 2: 1-30.)

馬淑清、王秀紅、陳季員 (2011)。〈職場霸凌的概念分析〉，《護理雜誌》，58, 4: 81-86。(Ma, S.-C., Wang, H.-H., & Chen, J.-Y. [2011]. Conceptual analysis of workplace bullying. The Journal of Nursing, 58, 4: 81-86.)

焦興鎧 (1991)。〈美國之雇主對受雇者從事藥物及酒精檢驗所引起之法律爭議〉，《美國研究》，21, 1: 29-102。(Chiao, C.-K. [1991]. The emerging legal issues concerning drug and alcoholic testing in the workplace in the United States. American Studies, 21, 1: 29-102.)

焦興鎧 (2001)。〈美國最高法院與工作場所性騷擾之爭議〉，《歐美研究》，31, 2: 325-420。(Chiao, C.-K. [2001]. United States supreme court and the controversies over sexual harassment in the workplace. EurAmerica, 31, 2: 325-420.)

焦興鎧 (2013)。〈美國最高法院對工作場所性騷擾爭議之最新判決——Crawford v. Nashville一案判決之評析〉，《歐美研究》，43, 2: 255-304。(Chiao, C.-K. [2013]. The newest case regarding sexual harassment in the workplace as decided by the U.S. Supreme Court—A review of Crawford v. Nashville. EurAmerica, 43, 2: 255-304.)