楊仁山、章太炎以「唯識」解莊析論－以真心派的唯識之詮釋

Interpretation of Chuang Tzu with the ＂Consciousness-only Theory＂ by Yang Jen-Shan and Chang Tai-Yen-Real Mind School's Interpretation of ＂Consciousness Only＂

邱敏捷(Ming-Chieh Chiu)

《佛學研究中心學報》 11期 (2006/07) Pp. 201+203-243

摘要

清末民初，中國處境困窘，各種救國口號此起彼落，改革、立新之風潮尤熾，「佛教救國」即其中一個環節。因緣際會，「唯識學」以其理論精密，受到有學之士的重視。楊仁山、章太炎因熏習唯識學，分別在《南華經發隱》與《齊物論釋》，以「唯識」解莊。前者援引「唯識名相」，後者則採用唯識「四尋思」、「藏識」、「三性」等概念詮釋《莊子》。這種「比附」作法，雖未必充分貼近《莊子》原意，但他們「以唯識解莊」，在「以佛解莊」之學術思想史上實有其創新的意義。

關鍵字

楊仁山 ； 章太炎 ； 唯識 ； 《莊子》

並列摘要

At the end of the Ching Dynasty and the beginning of the Republic of China, China was in a difficult situation, and all kinds of slogans for saving the nation rang out continuously. Reformation and innovation were thus become trends of the time. ＂Saving the nation by Buddhism＂ was one of the slogans. Occasionally, the philosophy of ＂consciousness only＂ attracted scholars' attention for its precise theory. Yang Jen-Shan and Chang Tai-Yen, who both studied the consciousness-only theory, interpreted ＂Chuang Tzu＂ from the view point of ＂consciousness only＂ in their works Nan Hua Jing Fa Yin and Chi Wu Lun Shih respectively. The former used ＂the terms of consciousness only theory＂ to explain Chuang Tzu, while the later interpreted Chuang Tzu by using the concepts of ＂four Nikayas＂ (four types of investigations of dharmas), ＂alaya consciousness＂ (store consciousness), ＂three nature＂, etc. The ＂comparison＂ methods they used were not necessarily able to discover the original intent of Chuang Tzu, but their ＂interpretation of Chuang Tzu with the consciousness-only theory＂ did have a significant new meaning in the intellectual history of ＂interpretation of Chuang Tzu with Buddhism＂.

並列關鍵字

Yan Jen-Shan ； Chang Tai-Yen ； consciousness only ； ＂Chuang Tzu＂

參考文獻

黃錦鋐(1991)。章太炎先生的〈齊物論釋〉。國文學報。20，40。

邱敏捷(2004)。以「空」解莊之考察。南師學報。38(1)

方以智(2005)。藥地炮莊。南大學報。39(1)

沈葆楨、寶鋆修(1974)。籌辦夷務始末。台北:文海。

李東源、鄭振鐸編(2002)。晚清文選。北京:中國社會科學。