性別平等教育議題融入課程與教學之意義與爭議及對師資培育之啟示

Meaning and Controversy of Integrating Gender Equity Issue into Curriculum and Instruction and Their Implications for Teacher Education

楊巧玲(Chiao-Ling Yang)

《課程與教學》 25卷2期 (2022/04) Pp. 1-27

https://doi.org/10.6384/CIQ.202204_25(2).0001

摘要

學校該教什麼是課程研究與教學實務的核心議題，或稱文化戰爭，其底蘊是對社會權力關係轉移之焦慮。本文採再概念化學派的觀點，聚焦在性別平等教育被視為重大議題之一，納入正式課程、融入領域教學的政策與實施，藉由歷史化以闡述其間意義、探究所引發的爭議。就前者而言，九年一貫課程改革是性別平等教育議題從空無課程到正式課程之分水嶺，十二年國教新課綱則是性別平等教育議題從獨立課綱到附屬領綱之轉捩點。就後者而論，從1998年《國民教育階段九年一貫課程綱要總綱》至2014年《十二年國民基本教育課程綱要總綱》，期間性平教育議題引發不少相關爭議，或在課程決定階段歷經掙扎，或在實施之後備受挑戰，至少可分三個向度：課程位階的角力、性平概念的論戰、教學實施的拉鋸。最後以重思在強調永續發展的當今性平教育對師資培育有何啟示作結。

關鍵字

再概念化 ； 性別平等教育 ； 師資培育 ； 課程改革 ； 議題融入

並列摘要

What schools should teach is a core focus of curriculum studies and teaching practices, a kind of ＂culture war＂ which connotes anxiety regarding shifting power relations in society. Utilizing the perspective of reconceptualization, this study explored gender equity education, related policies, its integration into formal curricula, and the surrounding controversy by historicizing its evolution. The Grade 1-9 Curriculum Reform moved gender equity education from the null curriculum into the formal curriculum, and the independent curriculum guidelines were reduced into an appendix of the curriculum guidelines for each subject in the 12 -Year Basic Education system. During the transition from the Grade 1-9 Curriculum to the 12-Year Basic Education system, controversy emerged in three regards: (1) curricular status, (2) gender equity education, and (3) teaching practices. Some of these controversies emerged when the new curriculum was established, whereas others emerged only after it was implemented. This study concludes with a reconsideration of the significance of gender equity education for teacher education amid concerns regarding Sustainable Development Goals, one of which is gender equality.

並列關鍵字

reconceptualization ； gender equity education ； teacher preparation ； curriculum reform ； integration of issues

參考文獻

王郁雯（2017）。從九年一貫課程到十二年國民基本教育：教師專業認同變化。課程研究，12（2），37-59。

王儷靜（2013）。重探性別融入教學之「融入」意涵。女學學誌，32，1-41。

王儷靜（2015）。12年國教的性別平等教育議題在哪裡？性別平等教育季刊，70，4-6。

王儷靜（2016）。12年國教的性別平等教育議題在哪裡？PartII。性別平等教育季刊，77，4-7。

王儷靜（2021）。議題教育的教育學討論。教育研究月刊，331，4-17。