綜合高中政策之評鑑與改進：方案理論評鑑的觀點

The Evaluation and Improvement of the Comprehensive High School Policy in Taiwan: An Approach of the Program Theory Evaluation

張嘉育(Chia-Yu Chang) ； 周愚文(Yu-Wen Chou) ； 張炳煌(Ping-Huang Chang)

《教育學刊》 33期 (2009/12) Pp. 35-74

https://doi.org/10.6450/ER.200912.0035

摘要

本研究旨在以「方案理論評鑑」模式，檢視綜合高中政策理論與實施的因果關係，除瞭解政策目標是否達成及確實執行外，也關切政策本身的理論假設是否周延。藉由文件分析、個別訪談、焦點團體訪談與問卷調查等方法，本研究獲致結論如下：一、綜合高中政策的規劃理論具合理性；二、綜合高中政策的實施理論確屬重要；三、綜合高中政策的方案改變理論具可行性；四、綜合高中政策實施理論雖獲落實但程度有別；五、實施理論在理想與實際間存有落差，問題出在執行層面。最後，本研究建議綜合高中政策推動應強化實施理論的落實，並可續採方案理論評鑑模式進行政策評鑑。

關鍵字

方案理論評鑑 ； 政策評鑑 ； 綜合高中

並列摘要

A number of researches and on-site evaluation reports on comprehensive high school (CHS) have been made since the Taiwanese government launched the policy of CHS. However, most of their findings were not tenable due to the imperfect and incomprehensive data and the aim of on-site evaluation was mainly to find the problems of implementation. Since the model of ”Program Theory Evaluation (PTE)”, a new approach of policy evaluation, was used to analyze the policy of CHS in Taiwan. The aims of this research were to: (1) probe into the change theory of policy of CHS in Taiwan; (2) evaluate the feasibility of change theory which the CHS policy is based on; (3) explore the policy implementation of the 'CHS policy, (4) make some suggestions. Document analysis, in-depth interview, focus group interview, and questionnaire survey were used, and some important findings were concluded.

並列關鍵字

program theory evaluation ； policy evaluation ； comprehensive high school

參考文獻

王麗雲、侯崇博、潘慧玲主編(2005)。教育評鑑的回顧與前瞻。臺北市:心理。

中華民國年鑑九十四年版

何金針(2003)。我國試辦綜合高中之現況與未來發展之研究。社會科學學報。11，85-116。

吳清基(1995)。綜合高中的理念與實施。教改通訊。11，48-51。

呂昆娣(2004)。我國綜合高中課程規劃與實施現況之研究(碩士論文)。國立政治大學教育學系中等學校教師在職進修班。