以合作賽局角度看待慈善機構與個案之間的配適問題

A Mechanism Application to Match Charities Organizations and Donees Based on Cooperative Game Approaches

褚志鵬(Chih-Peng Chu) ； 藍陳淯(Chen-Yu Lan)

《臺大社會工作學刊》 40期 (2019/12) Pp. 43-86

https://doi.org/10.6171/ntuswr.201912_(40).0002

摘要

目前慈善機構與個案端間的資源分配研究較少，在實務上也常看到照顧個案資源分配不均，有些照顧個案接收到同質性的福利物資過多，或是更需關懷個案卻無資源協助之現象，本研究利用合作賽局機制「延遲接受演算法」設計一個配適平台，作為慈善機構與照顧個案之間的媒合，慈善機構間可因資訊互通及透明化，使資源更有效利用，進而合作擬訂關懷計畫。本研究模擬不同情境，結果顯示「延遲接受演算法」之整體成效優於現行的配對機制與「波士頓配對機制」。本研究機制亦可作為社會工作人員決策之參考，以達到慈善機構之價值。

關鍵字

慈善機構與照顧個案 ； 配對機制應用 ； 延遲接受演算法 ； 波士頓機制

並列摘要

Few studies focus on the matching problem between charities organizations and donees. In the real world, there is an uneven distribution phenomenon among donees. Somet donee cases receive too much charity resources, while other cases with higher priority may receive no charities. This study applied a ＂deferred acceptance algorithm＂ to design a matching platform for charity organizations and donees. This platform makes the charity distribution process both logical and transparent; therefore, the charity organizations will distribute their resources more efficiently. In the three scenarios designed in this study, all the results support the conclusion that the deferred acceptance algorithm has better performance than the current matching mechanism and Boston matching mechanism. This platform can also serve as a reference for social workers in order to achieve the desired value of charities.

並列關鍵字

charity organizations and donees ； matching mechanism ； deferred acceptance algorithm ； Boston matching mechanism

參考文獻

王仕圖（2013）。〈非營利組織在社區照顧服務的協調合作：以社區照顧關懷據點為例〉，《臺大社會工作學刊》，27，185-228。doi: 10.6171/ntuswr2013.27.05 【Wang, S.-T. (2013). The coordination of nonprofit organizations in community care service: A research for the community care stations. NTU Social Work Review, 27, 185-228. doi: 10.6171/ntuswr2013.27.05】

王金永（2018）。〈精神病社區關懷照顧計畫：東部地區關懷訪視員的經驗與觀點〉,《臺大社會工作學刊》，37，1-46。doi: 10.6171/ntuswr2018.37.01 【Wang, J.-Y. (2018). Community care plan for people with mental illness: Care visitors’ experiences and perspectives in Eastern Taiwan. NTU Social Work Review, 37, 1-46. doi: 10.6171/ntuswr2018.37.01】

呂朝賢、王德睦、林怡婷、沈明彥（2009）。〈台灣兒童暨家庭扶助基金會經濟扶助個案給付動態：：以嘉義分事務所為例（1967-2008）〉，《臺大社會工作學刊》，20，57-92。doi: 10.6171/ntuswr2009.20.02 【Leu, C.-H., Wang, T.-M., Lin, Y.-T., & Sen, M.-Y. (2009). The dynamics of economic provisions derived from the cases of TFCF: An example of Chiayi Branch (1967-2008). NTU Social Work Review, 20, 57-92. doi: 10.6171/ntuswr2009.20.02】

林宜輝、陳怡如（2017）。〈國際兒童保護體制改革之制度論初探：以兒童保護與家庭支持典範交流為例，及其對臺灣兒保改革之啟發〉，《臺大社會工作學刊》，36，97-136。doi: 10.6171/ntuswr2017.36.03 【Lin, Y.-W., & Chen, Y.-J. (2017). An institutional approach to international child protection reforms: The exchange of child protection and family support paradigms and its implications for Taiwan’s policy reforms. NTU Social Work Review, 36, 97-136. doi: 10.6171/ntuswr2017.36.03】

孫仲山、蘇美蓉、施文玲（2005）。〈慈善捐贈行為之研究分析〉，《臺灣社會工作學刊》，3，99-143。doi: 10.29814/TSW.200501.0003 【Sun, C.-S., Su, M.-R., & Shih, W.-L. (2005). A study of donation behavior character. Taiwanese Social Work, 3, 99-143. doi: 10.29814/TSW.200501.0003】