台灣電視政論節目的議題論述策略：以“真調會覆議案大法官關說疑雲”爲例

The Discursive Strategies Used by Political Talk Shows in Taiwan: "The Suspicious Case of Grand Justice's Lobbying for the Reconsideration of the Truth Investigation Committee Statute" as an Example

孫秀蕙(Hsiu-Hui Sun) ； 陳儀芬(I-Fen Chen)

《中華傳播學刊》 16期 (2009/12) Pp. 45-92

https://doi.org/10.6195/cjcr.2009.16.05

摘要

本文檢視台灣2004年總統大選爭議後的電視政論節目，以「真調會覆議案大法官關說疑雲」為例，利用符號文本分析的方式，探討台灣特定社會脈絡中政論節目的議題論述策略，辨識其中的議題框架。研究發現，Bourdieu的「戲劇化」、「強制世界觀」等說法，不足以精確描述台灣政論節目的狀態：政論節目呈現出「台灣藍綠政黨對決連續劇」，不約而同使用「策略框架」的競逐現象。最後，本文針對台灣政論節目的問題，討論媒體責任並提出法規改善建議。

關鍵字

論述策略 ； 電視政論節目 ； 公共論述領域 ； 文本分析 ； 策略框架

並列摘要

The present study examines the political talk shows after the controversy of Taiwan presidential election in 2004. Taking ”the suspicious case of Grand Justice's lobbying for the reconsideration of the Truth Investigation Committee Statute” as an example, the study uses textual analysis to probe into political talk shows within the specific social context and discusses the discourse strategies of the political talk shows. In addition, the study applies framing theories to identify frame strategies used by guests in the discursive process. The study finds that Pierre Bourdieu's notions of ”dramatisation” and ”vision du monde” cannot adequately depict Taiwan's political talk shows. Nonetheless, these political talk shows, failing to function as a public sphere, present themselves together as ”the TV series of blue-green party conflicts in Taiwan” regardless of varied topics and issues in programs. Although their stances are distinctly different, both party members use ”strategy frames” when engaged in the political discourse. Finally, the paper reflects on both the media responsibility and media law in order to provide suggestions of improving the television political talk shows in Taiwan.

並列關鍵字

discursive strategy ； political talk shows ； the public sphere of discourse ； textual analysis ； strategy frame

參考文獻

台灣艾傑比尼爾森媒體研究()。

NOWnews

林富美(2006)。當新聞記者成為名嘴：名聲、專業與勞動商品化的探討。新聞學研究。83，43-81。

洪貞玲、劉昌德(2006)。傳播權觀點的商營廣電管制。中華傳播學刊。10，27-53。

張錦華(2007)。從公共領域理論及多元化報導觀點探討我國選舉新聞報導：以78年、81年、以及84年選舉新聞中的統獨議題爲例。新聞學研究。55，183-202。