對話即實踐：網絡學習社群專業資本積累之個案研究

Dialogue as Practice: A Case Study on the Accumulation of Professional Capital by the Networked Learning Communities

陳佩英(Pei-Ying Chen)

《教育科學研究期刊》 62卷3期 (2017/09) Pp. 159-191

https://doi.org/10.6209/JORIES.2017.62(3).06

摘要

本研究旨在探究網絡學習社群之教學探究活動及其專業資本積累之實踐路徑與意義。履行者個案由七位臺北市立六所公立高中的國文教師組成。本研究為期2年，資料蒐集包含深度訪談與焦點訪談、觀察紀錄、問卷與文件分析等。本研究結合網絡學習社群、專業資本與對話即實踐之概念，以之深描與詮釋該社群之發展歷程與專業資本累積之關聯。研究結果除了說明國內網絡學習社群的發展脈絡，也討論了履行者成員投入跨校社群的理由、在實踐中形塑社群主體、善用社群媒體平台打破時空限制、透過教學探究的文本生成循環而使得專業資本得以積累，以及跨校社群的網絡擴散和未來發展。社群成員因理念相通而集結，當成員參與備課－觀課－議課之時，便是創造第三空間的集體探究活動。跨校社群經由集體活動中的言談與文本的生成循環，漸漸形成跨文本的理解，共享的優勢言談可以穿越學校城牆與教室，形成具備公共議題的敘事文本，並於教學文本的生成循環中進行探討和反思，繼而共創教育價值並賦予課程與教學新的實踐意義。

關鍵字

專業資本 ； 對話即實踐 ； 網絡學習社群

並列摘要

This research explored the pedagogical inquiry activities of the networked learning communities (NLCs), and the path and meaning of its professional empowerment. The case study focused on a group of teachers named the ＂Navigators,＂ comprised of seven Chinese Literacy teachers from six public high schools in Taipei. This study lasted 2 years and data collection included in-depth interviews, focus group interviews, field observation, and document analysis. The concepts of NLCs, professional capital, and dialogue as practice were employed to provide thick description and a thorough interpretation of the processes and changes involved in the NLCs. The results explain the context in which the NLCs originated, the drivers of participation, how agency was developed through collaboration, the use of social media for constraint-free communication, the use of professional enquiry and reconstructed lesson texts for accumulation of professional capital, and the network expansion that led to further development of new NLCs. When participants gathered for meetings and held discussions regarding lesson plans and instructional observation, they created a ＂third space＂ for collective inquiry. Through cycles of professional dialogue and the recurrent production of lesson texts, a shared pedagogy was strengthened that guided professional discourse and enabled common understanding. This discourse was then continued within the teachers' respective schools to form a public narrative on educational practices. Along the process of recurrent production of talks and texts then practiced collaborative inquiry and reflection. This, in turn, shaped educational values and empowered the Navigators to be innovative with their curriculum and instruction.

並列關鍵字

dialogue as practice ； networked learning communities ； professional capital

參考文獻

林智中、張爽（2013）。香港高中課程改革：通識教育科的人力成本。課程與教學季刊，16（1），159-178。【Lam, C.-C., & Zhang, S. (2013). Senior secondary curriculum reform: The human costs of liberal studies in Hong Kong. Curriculum & Instruction Quarterly, 16(1), 159-178.】

陳佩英（2015）。結構縫隙、社群結連與教育學想像的實踐。中等教育，66（1），58-78。【Chen, P.-Y. (2015). Structural chasm, networked community, and pedagogical imaginary. Secondary Education, 66(1), 58-78. 】

楊佩文、卯靜儒（2015）。教育改革中構築的主體、意義與關係：臺北市跨校教師共同備課之經驗分享。中等教育，66（1），153-171。【Yang, P.-W., & Mao, C.-J. (2015). The building of subjects, meanings and relations in education reform－Experience of joint lesson planning shared by groups of Taipei teachers. Secondary Education, 66(1), 153-171. 】

陳佩英、焦傳金（2009）。分散式領導與專業學習社群之建構：一所高中教學創新計畫的個案研究。教育科學研究期刊，54（1），55-86。【Chen, P.-Y., & Chiao, C.-C. (2009). Distributed leadership and professional learning community: A case study of innovative teaching in a high school. Journal of Research in Education Sciences, 54(1), 55-86. 】

陳佩英、鄭美瑜、黃琪、鄭毓瓊、林雅婷（2016）。教育學想像的促能：跨校網絡學習社群與校本學習社群的共享願景實踐。教育研究月刊，265，91-109。【Chen, P.-Y., Zheng, M.-Y., Huang, Q., Zheng, Y.-Q., & Lin, Y.-T. (2016). Enabling pedagogical imaginary: Networked learning communities and school-based learning communities realizing shared visions. Journal of Education Research, 265, 91-109. 】