笠亭仙果《柳風花白波》論析：兼及與明清文藝的關連

An Analysis of Ryūtei Senka's Yanagi no Kaze Hana no Shiranami and Its Relationship with Ming-Qing Literature

蕭涵珍(Han-Chen Shiau)

《清華中文學報》 28期 (2022/12) Pp. 289-323

摘要

中日文化間存在深厚聯繫，諸多明清文藝經由江戶作家的改寫，以嶄新面貌獲得廣大讀者的喜愛。勃興於文化年間（1804－1818）的合卷亦不乏借鏡中國題材的佳作，不僅極富巧思，更是考察東亞文化交流樣貌的良好素材。笠亭仙果的合卷多方攝取中日故事，展現成熟的創作技巧。《柳風花白波》（1849）模仿近松門左衛門的歌舞伎《傾城弘誓舟》，融合馮夢龍輯《智囊》、趙吉士輯《寄園寄所寄》、草亭老人《娛目醒心編》的部分內容，參酌青山橘才子《東雲草》、道成寺故事，構成劇情曲折、趣味豐富的作品。本文藉由情節梗概、典據由來、寫作手法的分析，得以一窺中日文藝的融合與創新，認識此期合卷的創作特徵。此外，從主題選擇亦能看出《柳風花白波》與合卷《七組入子枕》第四、五編（1851－1852）的關連，有助理解作品的影響價值。

關鍵字

笠亭仙果 ； 智囊 ； 寄園寄所寄 ； 傾城弘誓舟 ； 合卷

並列摘要

There is a deep connection between Chinese and Japanese culture. A considerable number of literary and artistic works in the Ming and Qing dynasties were adapted by writers in the Edo Era, winning readers' favor with their novel modifications. Furthermore, there was an abundance of excellent Gōkan works, which flourished in the Bunka Era (1804-1818), that also drew on earlier Chinese writings. They are not only ingenious, but also constitute an excellent resource for examining the nature of cultural exchanges within East Asia. Ryūtei Senka's Gōkan works were inspired by plots from a variety of Chinese and Japanese stories, which shows his proficient writing skill. In one of his works, Yanagi no Kaze Hana no Shiranami (1849), he imitated Chikamatsu Monzaemon's Kabuki work, Keisei Guzei no Fune, fusing Feng Meng Long's Zhinang, Zhao Jishi's Jiyuan jisuoji, and part of Du Gang's (Caoting laoren) Yumu xingxin bian together. Moreover, Aoyama no Kitsusaishi's Shinonomegusa and his Dojoji story, provided a stimulus to Ryūtei Senka as well. By incorporating elements of the above works, he completed a riveting piece full of twists and turns. Through an analysis of the plot, the origins of the literary allusions, and the writing skill displayed in this story, it is possible to discern the innovations in, and fusion of, Chinese and Japanese literature, as well as grasp the main features of the writings of this period. Additionally, the connection between Yanagi no Kaze Hana no Shiranami and the fourth and fifth edition of the Gōkan work, Nanatsugumi Irekomakura (1851-1852), can be seen through the selection of its theme, which demonstrates the great influence of this work.

並列關鍵字

Ryūtei Senka ； Zhinang ； Jiyuanjisuoji ； Keisei Guzei no Fune ； Gōkan

參考文獻

〔宋〕李昉等編，《太平廣記》，臺北：文史哲出版社，1981 年，據無錫談愷刻本點校影印。

〔明〕馮夢龍，《智囊補》，魏同賢編，《馮夢龍全集》，冊 37、38，上海：上海古籍出版社，1993 年，據浙江圖書館藏明末天祿閣刻本影印。

〔清〕草亭老人，《娛目醒心編》，收入古本小說集成編委會編，《古本小說集成》，冊 50，上海：上海古籍出版社，1994 年，據乾隆五十七年（1792）刊本影印。

〔清〕趙吉士，《寄園寄所寄》，續修四庫全書編纂委員會編，《續修四庫全書•子部》，冊 1196，上海：上海古籍出版社，2002 年，據康熙三十五年（1696）刻本影印。

〔日〕源通具等撰，《新古今和歌集》，東京：出版年不明，藏於日本早稲田大学図書館。