是運氣還是能力?以Bootstrap方法分析國內股票型基金的投資績效

Can Mutual Fund “Stars” Really Pick Stocks? Evidence from Taiwan’s Equity Funds Using Bootstrap Analysis

陳伯岳(Po-yueh Chen)

指導教授 ： 黃志典

國立臺灣大學/管理學院/國際企業學研究所/碩士(2009年)

https://doi.org/10.6342/NTU.2009.00282

摘要

由於共同基金的績效無法維持一致的表現，因此本文探討共同基金的績效是來自於經理人的選股能力，或是運氣。本文利用三種模型估計1988年至2008年底的192檔國內股票型基金的績效指標，並以Bootstrap方法檢定這些基金的績效是來自基金經理人的選股能力還是運氣。本文發現，以CAPM模型衡量基金績效，績效優異的基金具有選股能力，大部分績效差的基金則是因為運氣較差，而不是因為選股能力較差，然而以三因子模型或四因子模型衡量基金績效，則會得到完全相反的結果。

關鍵字

共同基金 ； 選股能力 ； 運氣 ； Bootstrap分析法 ； Carhart四因子模型 ； Fama and French三因子模型 ； CAPM模型

並列摘要

This paper uses 192 domestic equity mutual funds as sample to examine if their investment performance comes from “luck” or otherwise. First, we use three models, namely CAPM, Fama and French`s 3-factor model and Carhart`s 4-factor model, to estimate the performance indicator （α） and the residuals of each fund. We then apply a Bootstrap analysis to examine if the investment performance comes from the funds` stock-picking ability or from luck.
We find（1）some of the out-performing funds, estimated by CAPM model , do have good stock-picking ability and most of the funds with poor performance are due to bad luck;（2）the findings are exactly opposite when Carhart 4-factor model or Fama and French model is used.

並列關鍵字

mutual funds ； stock-picking ability ； luck ； Bootstrap ； Carhart 4-factor model ； Fama and French model ； CAPM model

參考文獻

1. Alexander, Gordon J., Jeffery V. Bailey and William F. Sharpe, 1998, Investments, Prentice Hall.

2. Baks, Klaas P., Andrew Metrick and Jessica Wachter, 2001, “Should investors avoid all actively managed funds? A study in Bayesian performance evaluation.”Journal of Finance 56, 45–86.

3. Bickel, Peter J. and David A. Freedman, 1984, “Some asymptotics on the bootstrap”, Annals of Statistics 9, 1196–1271.

4. Blake, David and Allan Timmermann, 1998, “Mutual fund performance: evidence from the UK”, European Finance Review 2, 57–77.

5. Blake, Christopher R. and Matthew R. Morey, 2000, “Morningstar ratings and mutual fund performance”, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 35(3), 451-483.