以益本比和價格動能為基礎的混合型和掺雜型投資策略之實證研究-以台灣股市為例

Empirical Study of Mix and Blend Strategies Based on the Earnings-to-Price Ratio and Price Momentum–The Case for the Taiwan Stock Market

劉宜達(Yi-Dar Liu)

指導教授 ： 黃志典

國立臺灣大學/管理學院/國際企業學研究所/碩士(2008年)

https://doi.org/10.6342/NTU.2008.01081

摘要

本論文探討兩種合成投資策略：(1)買高益本比股票、賣低益本比股票，並且買高價格動能股票、賣低價格動能股票的「混合型投資策略」；(2)買高益本比、高價格動能股票，並且賣低益本比、低價格動能股票的「掺雜型投資策略」。本論文用兩種方法比較合成投資策略和原本的益本比投資組合(買高益本比股票、賣低益本比股票)、價格動能投資組合(買高價格動能股票、賣低價格動能股票)的績效：(1)比較平均異常報酬的t值；(2)比較異常報酬的平均值和標準差的信賴區間。本論文的樣本期間為1998年1月至2007年12月，樣本股票為曾在樣本期間上市的普通股。結果發現：(1)不管是用那一種方法，合成投資策略皆可能優於原本的投資組合；(2)儘管限制放空並扣除交易成本，合成投資策略仍然有可能打敗大盤。這些結果顯示，結合兩種負相關的選股指標可顯著地提昇投資績效。此外，本論文亦更新價值效應和動能效應在台灣股市的證據，並討論到價值因子和動能因子之間的關係。

關鍵字

混合型投資策略 ； 掺雜型投資策略 ； 益本比 ； 價格動能

並列摘要

This thesis examines two composite strategies: (1) the strategy of buying high earnings-to-price (EP) stocks, selling low EP stocks, buying high price momentum (PM) stocks, and selling low PM stocks, or the “mix strategy;” (2) the strategy of buying high EP, high PM stocks and selling low EP, low PM stocks, or the “blend strategy.” Two methods are used to compare the composite strategies with the original EP portfolio (buying high EP stocks and selling low EP stocks) and PM portfolio (buying high PM stocks and selling low PM stocks): (1) comparing average abnormal returns’ t-values; (2) comparing confidence intervals for abnormal returns’ means and standard deviations. Using the Taiwan stock market data from January 1998 to December 2007, we find that: (1) the composite strategies could outperform the original portfolios, regardless of the comparison method; (2) even though we impose short selling restrictions and high transaction costs on them, they could still beat the market. These results show that combining two negatively correlated stock selection indicators can significantly improve investment performance. Updated evidence on value and momentum effects and relations between value and momentum factors in the Taiwan stock market are also documented.

並列關鍵字

mixing ； blending ； earnings-to-price ratio ； price momentum

參考文獻

Fang, C.C., and Yau, M.C., 1998. The book-to-market phenomenon in Taiwan. Journal of Management 15 (3), 367-391. (方智強、姚明慶，1998，台灣上市公司的淨值市價比現象，管理學報，第15卷，第3期，367-391。)

Hung, J.H., and Lei, A., 2002. An empirical study on the relationship between stock return and firm size, stock price, price-to-earnings, and book-to-market. Management Review 21 (3), 25-48. (洪榮華、雷雅淇，2002，公司規模、股價、益本比、淨值市價比與股票報酬關係之實證研究，管理評論，第21卷，第3期，25-48。)

Ku, K.P., 2005. One-Factor, Three-Factor, or Four-Factor Models? Review of Securities & Futures Markets 17 (2), 101-146. (顧廣平，2005，單因子、三因子或四因子模式？，證券市場發展季刊，第17卷，第2期，101-146。)

Ting, P.H., and Tseng, C.C., 2005. Study of association between market states and momentum profits. Taiwan Banking & Finance Quarterly 6 (4), 1-19. (丁碧惠、曾家齊，2005，市場狀態與動能投資策略績效關聯性之研究，台灣金融財務季刊，第6卷，第4期，1-19。)

Chang, S.Y., 2006. Momentum strategy in Taiwan stock market. Unpublished master thesis. National Taiwan University, Taipei City. (張尚遠，2006，動量策略應用於台灣股市，未出版碩士論文，國立台灣大學國際企業學研究所。)