翁方綱《禮記附記》研究方法析論

On the Research Methodology of Wong Fang-kang’s “Notes to Liji”

許倍銘

指導教授 ： 賴貴三

國立臺灣師範大學/文學院/國文學系在職進修碩士班/碩士(2012年)

摘要

眾所周知，清朝乾隆、嘉慶之際（1736-1820），經學研究風氣十分盛行，而翁方綱（1733-1818）生逢時會，加上篤學勤撰，因此無論在經學、金石學、詩學、書學等方面，皆有豐碩的著作傳世，對學術研究的貢獻，可謂功不可沒。
翁方綱相關著論多散見各類著作之中，而禮學研究的專書，以《禮記附 記》為其代表。因此，本論文主要以《禮記附記》為研究文本，針對翁方綱的《禮記附記》從事學術研究方法上的探討；並且參稽翁方綱《復初齋集》與相關著述，以及現有的研究成果，辨章考鏡，歸納分析，總結集成，用以探討、述評翁方綱《禮記附記》的研究方法面向與其學術特色。
本論文共分為五章。第一章緒論，扼要說明本文的研究動機、研究方式、目的、文獻探討、研究方法與論文架構。第二章探討翁方綱學術及其著述，從其寫作《禮記附記》背景、版本的考述，以及《禮記附記》的寫作特色為重點。第三章探討翁方綱所引用歷代的述評，從其引用《禮記》研究注疏、《禮記》研究專書，以至於從各集解中所引出的學者說法為核心。第四章探討翁方綱《禮記附記》的門徑、進路與思想，進而研究其治禮的方法，以及其對《禮記》研究的思想。第五章為結論，整體統整翁方綱治禮的特色與精神。
筆者期望透過此五個章節的鋪陳、歸納與分析，能對翁方綱《禮記附記》研究方法有一全面性的認識與了解，不受限於既有的評價，進而能觀照出翁方綱的學術義蘊。

關鍵字

翁方綱 ； 《禮記附記》 ； 《復初齋集》 ； 《五經附記》 ； 乾嘉學派

並列摘要

It is commonly known that the Confucian classics studies were popular among the scholars of the eras of Qian-long and Jia-qing of Qing Dynasty (1736-1820). Not only was Wong Fang-kang (1733-1818) among them, but also he had worked hard scholastically, so that he made remarkable academic contribution with abundant writings on Confucian classics studies, epigraphy, poetics as well as calligraphy.
While Wong’s dissertations scatter in his works of various categories, his books dedicated to the study of Liji are represented by the Notes to Liji. This paper thus explores the research methodology of the Notes to Liji based on its texts, with reference made to Wong’s Fuchu-zhai Collection and related works along with existed research results. By literature review, origin tracking, generalization, analysis and summarization, the dimension of research methodology in the Notes to Liji and the academic features thereof were explored and commented.
This thesis comprises five chapters. Chapter one, an introduction, delineates the research motivation, approach, objective, literature review, methodology and thesis framework of the paper. Chapter two explores Wong’s scholarship and writings, referencing the background and versions of his writing of Notes to Liji with focus on the characteristics of his composition thereof. Chapter three examines the past comments Wong cited, centering the commentaries on the Liji, books dedicated to Liji and researchers’ arguments derived from various volumes. Chapter four explores Wong’s approach to and contemplation of the Notes to Liji and investigates his research methodology of Liji as well as his thought in the study of Liji. Chapter five, conclusions, summarizes the characteristics and spirit of Wong’s study of Liji.
Through the depictions, generalization and analysis of these chapters, the author hopes to be able to provide an overall understanding, without the constraint by existed evaluations, of Wong’s research methodology of his Notes to Liji and to reflect his scholastic meaning.

並列關鍵字

Wong Fang-kang ； Notes to Liji ； Fuchu-zhai Collection ； Notes to the five classics ； Qian-Jia School

參考文獻

3.李豐楙：〈翁方綱著述考〉，《書目季刊》，第8卷第3期，1974年12月，頁39-58。

6.吳銘能：〈銖積寸累，蔚為大觀──沈津輯《翁方綱題跋手札集錄》書後〉，《書目季刊》，第37卷第1期，2003年6月，頁69-91。

7.吳銘能：〈沈津著《翁方綱年譜》暨輯《翁方綱題跋手札集錄》補遺〉，《中國文哲研究通訊》，第16卷第1期，2006年3月，頁129-151。

12.陳鴻森：〈翁方綱年譜補正〉，《中國文哲研究集刊》，第25期，2004年9月，頁287-289。

21.（清）朱彝尊：《經義考》，臺北：中央研究院中國文哲研究所，1997年6月。