A large amount of logic reasoning knowledge is adopted in the Taiwan and Hong Kong detective fictions, especially the reasoning methods of the inductive reasoning, the deductive reasoning and the backtracking reasoning. The reasoning fictions from Hong Kong and Taiwan have something in common while using these methods to create, but what is more attractively to readers is their respective preference when they select the specific ways. In sum, Taiwan reasoning fictions place extra emphasis on incomplete induction of the inductive reasoning, but Hong Kong detective fictions place extra emphasis on the complete induction. In the deductive reasoning, Taiwan reasoning fictions place extra emphasis on the relation reasoning, and Hong Kong detective fictions place extra emphasis on the direct reasoning and Syllogism. In the backtracking reasoning, Taiwan reasoning fictions place extra emphasis on the complicated backtracking reasoning, and Hong Kong detective fictions place extra emphasis on the simple backtracking reasoning.