共識論述與差異政略思想在學校行政革新上的和合與適用性：Habermas、Lyotard與中國「道」思想的詮釋性應用

The Integration of ＂Consensus Discourse＂ and ＂Politics of Difference＂ in Seeking Appropriate Innovations in School Administrations: an Interpretive Application of Habermas's, Lyotard's, and Chinese Daoist Theories

黃宗顯(Tzung-Hsien Huang)

《教育研究集刊》 49:2期 (2003/06) Pp. 97-115

https://doi.org/10.6910/BER.200306_(49-2).0004

摘要

本文旨在探討批判理論學者J. Habermas的共識論述、後現代思想家J. F. Lyotard的差異政略、以及中國「道」思想三者在學校行政革新應用上的和合與實踐適用性。作者認為Habermas的共識論述可以為學校行政的共識性革新提供立論基礎；Lyotard的差異政略思想則為悖理性革新（paralogical innovation）建立合法性的堅實理據。共識性革新可以吸納校內外聚合傾向的革新能量，配合學校組織系統運作的需求，追求團體規約取向和集體意識型態下的革新作為和目標；悖理性革新吸納校內外疏離傾向的革新能量，關懷成員自主性需求，尋求個殊取向和特殊意識型態下的革新作為和功效。兩種革新都有其適用空間，都為學校行政革新所必需，且各有其優點和限制。就如同中國「道」學中的「陽」與「陰」，兩者的和合始構成學校行政革新的完整內涵，而兩者間有如陰陽辯證般的動態衍化特性，亦甚富學校行政革新的啟示。本文逐一析述這些立論的內涵與融通應用性。

關鍵字

共識論述 ； 差異政略 ； 學校行政革新

並列摘要

This article attempts to form a complementary framework for appropriate innovations in school administrations by integrating the theoretical perspectives of Habermas's consensus discourse, Lyotard's politics of difference, and Chinese Daoism. Habermas's thinking on consensus discourse offers a theoretical basis for consensus innovations in school administration, whereas Lyotard's thoughts on politics of difference legitimate school administrative paralogical innovations. Consensus innovations pursue school improvements under the mandate of group regulations and collective ideologies. Paralogical innovations, on the other hand, look for school progress by satisfying idiosyncratic needs as well as particular ideologies. Just as ＂Ying＂ and ＂Yang＂ constitute a complementary structure and dynamic relationship in Chinese Daoism, both consensus innovations and paralogical innovations are mutually constitutive in school administrations. Their theoretical inter-relationship and appropriate application are discussed in this paper.

並列關鍵字

consensus discourse ； politics of difference ； school administrative innovations

參考文獻

Best, S.,Kellner, D.(1991).Postmodern theory: Critical interrogations..

Habennas, J.(1979).Communication and the evolution of society..

Habennas, J.(2001).Contribution to a discourse theory of law and democracy..The new social theory reader.

Habennas, J.(2000).Relations to the world and aspect of rationality in four sociological concepts of action..The Habennas reader.

Habennas, J.(1984).The theory of communicative action(vol. 1).