Remolding Aesthetic Paradigm for Chinese Theater: Yu Shangyuan's Qinxian Articles and the American New Stagecraft Movement

李佳偉(Barbara Jiawei Li)

《翻譯學報》 新6卷2期 (2022/12) Pp. 131-166

摘要

Offering to fill in a gap in the modern Chinese theater history, this paper probes into the famous Chinese dramatist Yu Shangyuan's 余上沅 Qinxian 芹獻 series of articles which was published between 6 January and 23 May 1924 and has been received limited scholarly attention due to its scattered topics and equivocal wording. Via textual analysis and contextual investigation, this paper finds that Qinxian articles are not all original compositions but contain many unmarked translations rendered from the works concerning the ＂aesthetic paradigm,＂ an antirealistic theatrical scheme derived from the American New Stagecraft Movement. Based on the aesthetic paradigm, Yu Shangyuan devised a similar theatrical scheme in Qinxian, covering four facets: simple and symbolic stage sets decorated with lines, masses, and expressive lights; powerful anti-Ibsenite artist director; non-Ibsenian poetic drama; and presentational acting. Upon comparing Qinxian with the National Theater Movement's propositions, this paper finds that the movement's main arguments largely echo the key notions of Qinxian, indicating the movement's umbilical tie to Qinxian and, more at large, to the American New Stagecraft Movement. The analysis of Qinxian provides perspectives for the understanding of the aesthetic stance of the National Theater Movement, shedding light on the new insights that translation studies can bring to theater historiography.

關鍵字

Yu Shangyuan ； Qinxian ； the National Theater Movement ； the New Stagecraft Movement ； aesthetic paradigm

參考文獻

Appia, Adolphe (1962). Music and the Art of the Theatre. Coral Gables, FL: University of Miami Press.

Beacham, Richard (2013). Adolphe Appia: Artist and Visionary of the Modern Theatre. London: Routledge.

Bloom, Thomas Alan (1996). Kenneth Macgowan and the Aesthetic Paradigm for the New Stagecraft in America. New York: Peter Lang.

Boyd, Ernest Augustus (1917). The Contemporary Drama of Ireland. Boston: Little, Brown.

Brock, Henry (1924). “The Master Magic of Max Reinhardt.” New York Times, 20 January, 30.