齊國的視角－楚漢之際至漢初幾個重要階段的天下變局之詮釋

The Qi Domain's Perspective: An Analysis of Several Important Developments in the Transition from the Chu- Han Conflict to the Early Han

林聰舜(Lin Tsung-shun)

《清華學報》 47卷3期 (2017/09) Pp. 473-508

https://doi.org/10.6503/THJCS.2017.47(3).02

摘要

齊國的視角，包括從齊國的角度觀看天下，以及聚焦齊國在天下變局中扮演的角色。此一探討可以跳出傳統研究聚焦於關中的歷史詮釋，在角度互換過程中，形成多元角度的視域，理解權力中心與地方的力量如何共構並推進歷史的發展。本文透過發生在齊國的三個重要事件重新詮釋天下變局，齊國此一爭衡天下的重要力量被凸顯了，田氏兄弟與韓信用齊的得失，以及曹參相齊的意義也得到進一步的理解與詮釋，而聚焦於關中權力中心的傳統歷史詮釋也得到不同視域的補充。而齊地優越的環境與強烈的共同體意識，使齊國在亂世易於割據獨立，但也容易使據齊者產生孤立主義的思維，自外於天下大局，這是齊地特殊的條件與歷史傳統形成的特色，值得治史者注意。

關鍵字

楚漢之際 ； 齊國視角 ； 田橫 ； 蒯通 ； 韓信 ； 曹參

並列摘要

This study analyzes the period between the fall of the Qin and the rise of the Han from the perspective of the Qi 齊 domain, seeking to determine the role Qi played in this momentous historical event. In contrast to traditional studies, which focus exclusively on the Guanzhong 關中 area, the use of this perspective sheds light on the interaction between local and central authorities from a different point of view. In addition to the traditional perspective of “inside (central) to outside (local),” the adoption of the Qi domain's perspective reveals how the operation of central and local authorities influenced historical development. This article begins by discussing why the Qi domain had the power to play an important role at this decisive historical moment. It then advances a new interpretation of the historical changes that took place in the transition between the Chu-Han conflict and the early Han by analyzing three important incidents that occurred in Qi. This analysis highlights the importance of Qi, sheds light on the propriety of the actions of the Tian brothers and Han Xin 韓信, and explicates the effects of Cao Shen 曹參's conduct as prime minister. In addition, the traditional explanation for these events, which focused on the central authorities in Guanzhong, is reinterpreted from a different point of view. The article concludes that Qi's extraordinary natural environment and strong sense of community enabled the domain to remain independent and isolated in troubled times, and that Qi's unique circumstances are worthy of historical inquiry.

並列關鍵字

the transition from Chu to Han ； the Qi domain's perspective ； Tian Heng 田橫 ； Kuai Tong 蒯通 ； Han Xin 韓信 ； Cao Shen 曹參

參考文獻

阿部幸信 Abe Yukinobu 著，徐冲 Xu Chong 譯，〈「統治系統」論的射程〉“‘Tongzhi xitong’ lun de shecheng”，《早期中國史研究》Zaoqi Zhongguo shi yanjiu，3.1，臺北 Taipei：2011，頁137-154。譯自《日本秦漢史研究》Riben Qin Han shi yanjiu，11，東京 Tokyo：2011。

司馬遷 Sima Qian，《史記》Shiji，北京 Beijing：中華書局 Zhonghua shuju，2013，點校本二十四史修訂本 Dianjiaoben ershisishi xiudingben。

吳見思 Wu Jiansi 評點，《史記論文》Shiji lunwen，臺北 Taipei：臺灣中華書局 Taiwan zhonghua shuju，1970。

呂祖謙 Lü Zuqian，《兩漢精華》Lianghan jinghua，收入黃靈庚 Huang Linggeng、吳戰壘 Wu Zhanlei主編，《呂祖謙全集》Lü Zuqian quanji第7冊，杭州 Hangzhou：浙江古籍出版社 Zhejiang guji chubanshe，2008。

林伯桐 Lin Botong ，《史記蠡測》Shiji lice，收入張新科 Zhang Xinke主編，《史記文學研究典籍叢刊》Shiji wenxue yanjiu dianji congkan 第1輯，西安 Xi’an：陝西師範大學出版總社 Shanxi shifan daxue chuban zongshe，2015。