賭博偏好、交易型態與樂透股超額報酬共變的關聯性

The Study of Gambling Preference, Trading Pattern and Excess Comovement in Lottery-Like Stock Returns

王子湄(Zi-Mei Wang) ； 樓楠萱(Nan-Hsuan Lou)

《臺大管理論叢》 31卷3期 (2021/12) Pp. 85-159

https://doi.org/10.6226/NTUMR.202112_31(3).0003

摘要

本文探討臺灣股市法人與散戶交易是否造成樂透股超額報酬共變，以日內逐筆委託衡量交易型態，包含委託比率、急單比率與買賣超共變，對於「散戶是造成樂透股超額報酬共變主要來源」提供直接證據。我們發現：（1）散戶交易集中在樂透股，不僅交易頻繁、下單積極，會對不同樂透股一起買賣超，當散戶對樂透股買賣超共變增加，樂透股超額報酬共變會提高。（2）有些法人也會交易樂透股，但下單比率低，而且法人交易會減弱樂透股超額報酬共變。（3）當整體市場投機氛圍提高（如市場情緒高漲、不關注樂透、農曆新年期間、景氣佳等時），散戶會一起提高樂透需求，樂透股超額報酬共變更明顯。（4）財報宣告月份也會強化散戶交易與樂透股報酬共變關係，但個股賭博交易活動不影響研發支出或財報品質。

關鍵字

賭博偏好 ； 超額報酬共變 ； 買賣超共變 ； 樂透股 ； 下單行為

並列摘要

The study investigates whether stock trading made by institutional and retail investors results in excess return comovement of lottery-like stocks in the Taiwanese stock market. Order-level data, such as order ratio, immediacy ratio, and order flow comovement, are used to determine trading patterns in the market, and direct evidence is provided to demonstrate that individual investors are the main cause of excess return comovement of lottery-like stocks. We find that (1) individual investors concentrate their trading on lottery-like stocks, make frequent trades, place aggressive orders, and have correlated order flows for various lottery-like stocks. A high level of comovement in retail investors' order flows for lottery-like stocks is associated with a high level of comovement among the stocks' excess returns. (2) Although institutional investors also trade lottery-like stocks, their order ratio is lower, and their trading reduces the excess return comovement of lottery-like stocks. (3) When overall market behavior leans toward speculation (e.g., in a bullish market, paying little attention to the lottery market, during the Chinese New Year period, or periods of economic boom), retail investors exhibit a high demand for lottery-like stocks, which in turn strengthens the excess return comovement of these stocks. (4) Retail investors' trading of lottery-like stocks and the return comovement of these stocks also increase during months when financial statements are released. However, gambling trading of individual stocks does not affect the expenditure on research and development or the quality of financial statements.

並列關鍵字

gambling preference ； excess return comovement ； order flow comovement ； lottery-like stock ； order submission behavior

參考文獻

Agarwal, V., Jiang, L., and Wen, Q. 2020. Why do mutual funds hold lottery stocks?. (Georgetown McDonough School of Business Research Paper No. 3164692), Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, doi:http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3164692

Byun, S. J., Goh, J., and Kim, D. H. 2020. The role of psychological barriers in lottery-related anomalies. Journal of Banking & Finance, 114, Article 105786. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbankfin.2020.105786

Li, F., Lin, C., and Lin, T. C. 2021. Salient anchor and analyst recommendation downgrade. Journal of Corporate Finance, 69, Article 102033. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcorpfin.2021.102033

王朝仕，2014，以樂透觀點檢視現金增資股票申購需求，臺大管理論叢，24 卷2 期：53-82。(Wang, Chao-Shi. 2014. Using the lottery view to analyze the subscription fads of SEOs. NTU Management Review, 24 (2): 53-82.)

王銘駿、陳宜伶、吳昭億與林韋伶，2014，誰在交易樂透性質的選擇權，應用經濟論叢，96 期：191-228。(Wang, Ming-Chun, Chen, Yi-Ling, Wu, Chao-Yi, and Lin, Wei-Ling. 2014. Who gambles in the option market?. Taiwan Journal of Applied Economics, 96: 191-228.)