我國制定意定監護制度之芻議

Proposal for Legislation to Voluntary Custody System in Taiwan

鄧學仁(Shyue-Ren Teng)

《臺北大學法學論叢》 90期 (2014/06) Pp. 91-157

摘要

監護制度之本意在於保護意思能力欠缺之人，其中成年監護制度特別置重於保護欠缺意思能力之老人，所謂保護在制度之設計上必須尊重老人之自我決定權，使老人藉由本制度之保護，得以安養天年。我國雖於2009年大幅修正監護制度，將過去完全喪失行為能力之一元化禁治產制度，修正為監護與輔助之二元化制度，但因為未導入意定監護制度，使得修法之美意大打折扣。鑑於外國設計監護制度，均以意定監護為原則，法定監護為例外，此亦為回應老人自我決定權之需求，因此本文首先探討意定監護制度立法之背景，強調意定監護為主法定監護為輔乃先進國家立法潮流，其次，說明立法之必要性所在，在於使本人喪失意思能力後，仍能基於本人的意思及其所期待的方式受到照顧，讓本人的人格及尊嚴受到最大尊重，第三，參考美德日等先進國家意定監護制度之立法例，構思我國制定意定監護之立法原則與方向，第四，具體提出立法條文草案與理由，提供我國未來立法之參考，最後以意定監護制度之引進，並不是要取代法定監護制度，而是提供本人多一個選項，使其得依自己之需要選擇最適合之類型。亦即，立於被保護人之立場，而非聲請人之立場，設計出符合被保護人最佳利益之制度作為結論。

關鍵字

監護制度 ； 輔助制度 ； 意思能力 ； 成年監護 ； 自我決定 ； 意定監護 ； 法定監護

並列摘要

The intention of the custody systems is to protect the people who are lack of mental capacity. In these systems, Adult custody system specially focuses on the protection of elderly who are lack of mental capacity. Therefore, the protection of its institutions must respect the self-determinant of elderly, so by the protection of this system, elderly can reassure their old age. However, in 2009, custody systems in Taiwan were revised significantly. Therefore, the past unitary incompetent system became dual systems of custody and assistant. But unfortunately, voluntary custody system was not introduced, so the meaning of amended law has been reduced. To comply with the self-determinant of elderly and in view of that custody system in the design of many foreign is almost a principle, then, the legal custody system is exceptional. So first, this paper explores the background of voluntary custody system, with this, this paper is able to highlight the international trend. Second, this paper explains the need for legislation. In other words, even if the person lose mental capacity, are taken care of that person on the basis of their own making. As a result, the person's personality and dignity shall be respected to the maximum. Third, with reference to the voluntary custody system of foreign legislation, this paper can consider the principles and direction of a voluntary custody system of Taiwan. Fourth, as a reference for future legislation in Taiwan, this paper attempts to submit the article of the legislation. Finally, the introduction of voluntary custody system is not to switched the legal custody system. It provides another option to people. As a result, people can follow for their needs, and select the most appropriate type. In other words, from the perspective of those who are protected, it aims to design the optimum system.

並列關鍵字

custody systems ； assistant system ； mental capacity ； Adult custody system ； self-determinant ； voluntary custody ； legal custody

參考文獻

陳鴻基(2011)。英、美與我國成年監護制度之比較研究。中央警察大學法律學研究所=Law School, Central Police University=zhong yang jing cha da xue fa lu xue yan jiu suo。

楊惠雯(2003)。從美國法論我國高齡監護法制。國立政治大學法律學系學士後法學組=College of Law, National Chengchi University=guo li zheng zhi da xue fa lu xue xi xue shi hou fa xue zu。

李沃實(2006)。英國2005年意思能力法之概述。中央警察大學法學論集。13

林秀雄(2008)。論我國新修正之成年監護制度。月旦法學雜誌。164

劉得寬(1999)。意定監護制度立法上必要性─以成年（高齡者）監護制度為中心。法學叢刊。174