結婚的人比較快樂嗎？婚姻對幸福感的異質性處置效應分析

隨著臺灣社會結構及家庭規範的變化，晚婚及不婚逐漸取代普遍成婚，進入婚姻不再是每個人必經的人生途徑。在這樣的家庭及人口趨勢下，究竟婚姻是否能帶來幸福？而婚姻對幸福的影響是否又因人而異？本文旨在探討婚姻對於年輕成年人幸福感的影響，並著重在婚姻對幸福感的異質性處置效應分析（heterogeneous treatment effects）。透過使用2011年與2017年自臺北市、新北市及宜蘭縣所蒐集之「臺灣青少年成長歷程研究」（Taiwan Youth Project）長期追蹤資料，並運用傾向匹配權數（propensity score weighting）處理進入婚姻之可觀察選擇效應及估計婚姻對幸福感的異質性效應。研究結果顯示婚姻能顯著提升個人的幸福感且此影響並非來自選擇效應，而是來自因果效應；換言之，婚姻能促進所有男性及高結婚機率女性的幸福感，但對於低結婚機率的女性則無顯著助益或僅具備消極意義的助益。簡單來說，婚姻對於年輕成年人的幸福感仍是重要的社會決定因素，但僅限於男性及進入婚姻機率高的女性。婚姻對進入婚姻機率低的女性之幸福感的促進效應有限。政府在推動鼓勵婚姻的相關政策措施時，需瞭解何者能從婚姻中獲益且應避免一體適用的政策解決之道。

關鍵字

婚姻；社會選擇；傾向匹配權數；異質性處置效應；幸福感

並列摘要

With the transformation of social structures and family norms in Taiwan, universal marriage has been gradually replaced by the postponement and abandonment of marriage. Marriage is no longer a necessary and inevitable choice for individuals. Under this trend, it is therefore important to ask whether married people are happier than their unmarried counterparts and who benefits from marriage? This paper aims to investigate whether marriage confers happiness among young adults and who benefits from marriage in Taiwan. Specifically, this project will estimate the heterogeneous treatment effects of marriage on happiness, gauging who benefits from marriage. This paper utilizes the 2011 and 2017 Taiwan Youth Project (TYP), a longitudinal dataset collected in the northern part of Taiwan. Propensity score weighting is applied to address selection on observables and to estimate heterogeneous treatment effects of marriage on happiness. The results show that marriage has a positive effect on happiness, and this positive effect is not explained by selection effects. With regards to heterogeneous treatment effects of marriage, there are no heterogeneous effects of marriage on happiness for men. Marriage confers happiness for men, regardless of their propensity to get married. However, not all women benefit from marriage. Marriage only confers happiness for women who have a high propensity to get married but has limited benefits for those who have low propensity to get married. Simply speaking, the results suggest that marriage remains an important social determinant of happiness for young adult men and women who have high propensity to get married, but less so for women with low propensity to get married. Official policies that encourage marriage should target the right population and avoid a one-size-fits-all solution.

並列關鍵字

marriage ； social selection ； propensity score weighting ； heterogeneous treatment effects ； happiness

參考文獻

王德睦、張國偉 [Wang, Te-Mu and Kuo-Wei Chang]（2010）臺灣女性初婚率的量與步調。臺灣社會福利學刊，8(2): 241-278。“An Analysis of First Marriages among Females in Taiwan.” Taiwanese Journal of Social Welfare 8(2): 241-278. doi:10.6265/TJSW.2010.8(2)3

陶宏麟、鄭輝培 [Tao, Hung-Lin and Hui-Pei Cheng]（2019）快樂在年齡上的變化：U型的爭辯與臺灣兩性的差異。人口學刊，59: 35-88。“Happiness Changes with Age: U-Shape Debate and Gender Differences among Taiwanese.” Journal of Population Studies 59: 35- 88. doi:10.6191/JPS.201912_(59).0002

楊靜利 [Yang, Ching-Li]（2004）同居的生育意涵與臺灣同居人數估計。臺灣社會學刊，32: 189-213。“Fertility Implication and Estimate of Cohabitation in Taiwan.” Taiwanese Journal of Sociology 32: 189-213. doi:10.6786/TJS.200406.0189.

鍾宜吟、蔡明璋 [Jung, Yi-Yin and Ming-Chang Tsai]（2008）婚前同居、婚姻價值與婚姻滿意度：臺灣民眾的分析。研究臺灣，5: 43-72。“Cohabitation, Marriage Values and Marital Satisfaction: A Study of Taiwan Society.” Journal of Taiwan Studies 5: 43-72. doi:10.6456/JTS.200812.0043.

Axinn, W. G. and A. Thornton. 1992. “The Influence of Parental Resources on the Timing of the Transition to Marriage.” Social Science Research21(3): 261-285. doi:10.1016/0049-089X(92)90008-5.

主題瀏覽