課程革新制度化之探析

A Review of Innovative Curriculum Institutionalization

侯一欣(Yi-Hsin Hou) ； 高新建(Shin-Joann Gau)

《師資培育與教師專業發展期刊》 12卷1期 (2019/04) Pp. 59-82

https://doi.org/10.3966/207136492019041201003

摘要

課程革新的制度化約自1980年代始展開研究，其進展恰與制度理論的興革背景相呼應，皆受到理性選擇論、組織社會學和歷史制度主義等影響，而有不同的關注焦點。細究制度化的運作，發現其過程大抵可區分為：調控、規範和認知等三種模式；並且衍生相應的指標行為有：人們的從眾傾向、工作的例行化與規範價值的內在化等。長期以往，課程革新的制度化遠不若實施研究較受重視，學術研究累積的成果委實有限，期許未來該研究能與其它理論（如實施、擴散或推廣等）跨領域合作，豐實有關革新進程研究之全貌。

關鍵字

課程革新 ； 制度化 ； 制度理論 ； 課程實施 ； 課程擴散

並列摘要

Studies on innovative curriculum institutionalization (ICI) have burgeoned since the 1980s, synchronizing with the developmental background of the institutionalization theory. Both of them were influenced by the rational choice theory, organizational sociology, and historical institutionalism and appeared to focus on different issues. The three models of ICI consist of regulative, normative, and cognitive aspects, and some indicative behaviors are included, such as herd mentality, routine work, and enculturation of normative value. Compared to curriculum implementation, ICI was never highly respected as a field of study, and its accumulated research results are rather limited. Hopefully, future studies in the field of ICI may cooperate with other different domains (such as implementation or dissemination) in order to enrich the scope of research on the process of curriculum innovation.

並列關鍵字

curriculum innovation ； institutionalization ； institutionalization theory ； curriculum implementation ； curriculum diffusion

參考文獻

Welch, A. R.、吳姈娟（2009）。澳洲教育。載於楊深坑（主編），比較與國際教育（頁 436-481）。臺北市，高等教育出版社。[Welch, A. R. & Wu, L. C. (2009). Australian education. In S. K. Yang (Eds.), Comparative and international education (pp.436-481). Taipei, Taiwan: Higher Education Publishing.]

王恭志（2004）。新右派課程政策的評析與啟示。教育研究資訊，12（5），34-56。[Wang, G. J. (2004). Criticism of the new right curriculum policy with implications for curriculum reforms in Taiwan. Educational Research & Information, 12(5), 34-56.]

Berstein, B.（2006）。教育論述之結構化（王瑞賢譯）。臺北市：國立編譯館、巨流圖書。（原著出版於 2003 年）[Berstein, B.(2006). The Structuring of Pedagogic Discoursr. Taipei, Taiwan: Chu Liu Book Company.]

王盈勛（2013）。傳播新制度經濟史初探。傳播文化，12，1-15。[Wang, Y. X. (2013). New institutional economics as an approach to studying the history of communication. Journal of Communication & Culture, 12, 1-15.]

尹弘飈（2009）。論課程變革的制度化－基於新制度主義的分析。高等教育研究，30(4)，75-81。[Yin, H. B. (2009). The institutionalization of curriculum change: a neo-institutional analysis. Journal of Higher Education, 30(4), 75-81.]