探討護理指導方案經由改變不確定感刺激結構對不確定感之成效－初次罹患突發性聽力喪失病人

Exploring the Effectiveness of a Health Education Program on the Stimuli Frame and on Uncertainty in Patients with Sudden Hearing Loss

李雅惠(Ya-Hui Lee) ； 汪慧鈴(Huey-Ling Wang) ； 李中一(Chung-Yi Li) ； 蕭安穗(An-Suey Shiao) ； 杜宗陽(Tzong-Yang Tu)

《護理雜誌》 61卷3期 (2014/06) Pp. 36-44

https://doi.org/10.6224/JN.61.3.36

摘要

背景　不確定感會阻隔訊息接收及自我調適能力，繼而影響預後。突發性聽力喪失病患高度疾病不確定感與疾病瞭解程度不足以及訊息缺乏有關，然而目前尚缺乏明確的護理指導方案。目的　探討「一對一」口頭指導並配合手冊方式，對初次罹患不明原因、突發性聽力喪失病患，經由改變不確定感刺激結構對不確定感的成效。方法　採實驗性設計，將60位病患隨機分配於實驗組28位以及控制組32位。並以問卷方式收集基本資料、不確定感刺激結構及疾病不確定感。全體研究對象於住院時立即給予常規照護，並於24小時內進行前測；之後實驗組立即予一對一護理指導方案介入，三天後全體研究對象接受後測。結果　護理指導介入，可以增加自覺疾病瞭解程度，提升對突發性聽力喪失疾病的自我了解及降低疾病不確定感。疾病不確定感隨著不確定感刺激結構認知程度的增加而下降。經由介入措施增加不確定感刺激結構的認知程度，而間接降低疾病不確定感。結論／實務應用　個別性護理指導配合手冊運用，可提供病患明確的訊息來源，有效增加突發性聽力喪失病患對自我疾病的了解以及降低不確定感，並可提供臨床護理指導之參考。

關鍵字

突發性感覺神經性聽力喪失 ； 疾病不確定感 ； 不確定感刺激結構 ； 護理指導

並列摘要

Background: Uncertainty may limit communication and affect the ability of patients to adapt to their illness. A high level of uncertainty in patients concurrent with sudden hearing loss has been related to poor comprehension of communications and poor illness understanding. Currently, there is no any certain standard information sheet in the clinical setting. Purpose: This study evaluates the effect of a one-to-one oral instruction strategy combined with an information sheet firstly on the stimuli frame and then on uncertainty in patients suffering from idiopathic sudden sensorineural hearing loss. Method: An experimental design was employed and 60 patients were randomly assigned to either the experimental group (n = 28) or the control group (n = 32). A structured questionnaire that included the stimuli frame of uncertainty and the Mishel uncertainty illness scale was used to collect data. All samples received regular care following admission to the hospital and received the pretest within 24 hours after admission. The experimental group received the one-to-one oral instruction strategy combined with an information sheet immediately after the pretest. All participants completed the posttest three days later. Results: The health education program increased perceived understanding of illness in patients with the sudden hearing loss, and reduced their illness uncertainty. Perceived understanding of illness was negatively related to the level of illness uncertainty. The stimuli frame of uncertainty acted as a mediator between the intervention and the uncertainty. The intervention increased the level of cognition of the stimuli frame of uncertainty and then indirectly lowered the uncertainty level. Conclusions / Implications: These findings support the effectiveness of the individual health education strategy with the information sheet in delivering to patients critical information about their condition and treatment. Moreover, this intervention may effectively increase illness cognition and reduce uncertainty in patients with sudden hearing loss. Clinical nurse staffs may use the findings of this study to improve their health education efficacy.

並列關鍵字

sudden sensorineural hearing loss ； uncertainty in illness ； stimuli frame of uncertainty ； health education program

參考文獻

方惠珍、劉介宇、戴蕙蓮、陳治平、高美玲（2011）．健康諮詢介入措施對非住院高危險妊娠孕婦不確定感、壓力與生產結果之成效．護理暨健康照護研究，7（1），3－13。[Fang, H. C., Liu, C. Y., Day, H. L., Chen, C. P., & Gau, M. L. (2011). Uncertainty, stress, and birth outcomes in non-hospitalized, high-risk pregnancy women: The effectiveness of health consultation. Journal of Nursing and Healthcare Research, 7(1), 3－13.] doi:10.6225/JNHR.7.1.3

李雅惠、汪慧鈴、李中一、蕭安穗、杜宗陽（2012）．突發性聽力喪失住院病人疾病不確定感及其影響因素之探討．護理暨健康照護研究，8（2），149－157。 [Lee, Y. H., Wang, H. L., Li, C. Y., Shiao, A. S., & Tu, T. Y. (2012). Illness uncertainty and related factors in patients with sudden hearing loss. Journal of Nursing and Healthcare Research, 8(2), 149－157.] doi:10.6225/JNHR.08.2.149

杜金錠、陳品玲、許　雅（2004）．在台灣現行健保給付制度下乳癌手術病人疾病不確定感及出院護理指導需求之初探．腫瘤護理雜誌，4（1），1－13。[Tu, C. T., Chen, P. L., & Hsu, Y. (2004). The pilot study of uncertainty in illness and patient-education needs before discharge among breast cancer patients post operation under the current NHI reimbursement policy in Taiwan. The Journal of Oncology Nursing, 4(1), 1－13.]

林明珍、顧乃平（1993）．團體衛教對改善心肌梗塞病人認知與壓力之成效探討．護理研究，1（4），341－350。[Lin, M. C., & Ku, N. P. (1993). Effects of group teaching program on improving knowledge and lessening stress of myocardial infarction patients. Nursing Research (Taiwan), 1(4), 341－350.]

許淑蓮、黃秀梨（1996）．Mishel疾病不確定感量表之中文版測試．護理研究，4（1），59－68。[Sheu, S. L., & Hwang, S. L. (2001). Validation of Chinese version of Mishel's uncertainty in illness scale. Nursing Research (Taiwan), 4(1), 59－68.]