室內設計之新評分方法

A New Assessment Method of the Interior Design

呂文堯(Wen-Yao Lu) ； 王維歆(Wei-Xin Wang) ； 郭倩彣(Chien-Wen Kuo) ； 林敏哲(Ming-Che Lin)

《建築學報》 103期 (2018/03) Pp. 1-15

https://doi.org/10.3966/101632122018030103001

摘要

本文採用模糊偏好順序評價法(Fuzzy TOPSIS)及層級分析法(AHP)結合偏好順序評價法(TOPSIS)來進行室內設計評分，期望能建立一套客觀的室內設計新評分方法。本研究先由現有的參考文獻中取得6個室內設計評分準則。再透過專家問卷結果並藉由模糊德菲法，刪除其中一個未通過篩選門檻之評分準則。研究結果顯示，Fuzzy TOPSIS或AHP結合TOPSIS 皆可得到客觀之評分結果。Fuzzy TOPSIS之分析程序較AHP結合TOPSIS複雜，然而Fuzzy TOPSIS之問卷調查執行方式及操作過程則較AHP結合TOPSIS簡單。

關鍵字

模糊偏好順序評價法 ； 層級分析法 ； 偏好順序評價法 ； 模糊德菲法

並列摘要

This study proposes the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) integrated TOPSIS (Technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution) as well as Fuzzy TOPSIS to assess the interior design diagrams. Six criteria to assess the interior design diagram are obtained firstly from the available references. One criterion is deleted using the Fuzzy Delphi Method through the results of experts' questionnaires. The present study indicates that the rankings order of interior design diagram assessment can be determined objectively by either the AHP integrated TOPSIS or the Fuzzy TOPSIS. The analysis procedure of Fuzzy TOPSIS is more complicate than that of AHP integrated TOPSIS. However, the work of experts' questionnaires of Fuzzy TOPSIS is much easier than those of AHP integrated TOPSIS.

並列關鍵字

Fuzzy TOPSIS ； Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) ； TOPSIS ； Fuzzy Delphi Method

參考文獻

王紀鯤（1999）。建築教育中的評圖制度。建築學報，(30)，93-112 。Wang, C. K. (1999). The research for the jury system of the education of architecture. Journal of Architecture, (30), 93-112.

呂文堯，陳葶栩，張震鐘（2015）。以TOPSIS法評估室內設計圖。技術學刊，30(3)，151-161。Lu, W. Y., Chen, T. X., & Chang, C. C. (2015).TOPSISto assess the interior design diagrams. Journal of Technology, 30(3), 151-161.

畢威寧（2005）。結合AHP與TOPSIS法於供應商績效評估之研究。科學與工程技術期刊，1(1)，75-83。Pi, W. N. (2005). Supplier evaluation using AHP and TOPSIS. Journal of Science and Engineering Technology, 1(1), 75-83.

第六屆夆禾盃全國室內設計競圖比賽（2013）。活動辦法簡章http://design.apex.tw/designaward/2013/activ04.html。The competition rule of the Fenghenational interior design competition cup (2013).http://design.apex.tw/designaward/2013/activ04.html.

第二屆特力家居盃全國室內設計競圖大賽辦法（2013）。http://www.cycu-iidc.org/decorhouse/。The competition rule of the I-HOUSE interior design competition cup national competition held in Taiwan (2013). Accessed July 10. http://www.cycu-iidc.org/decorhouse/.