男同性戀與父母：現身的考量、策略、時機與後果

Gay Men and Their Parents: Decisions, Strategies, and Consequences of Coming Out

畢恆達(Herng-Dar Bih)

《女學學誌：婦女與性別研究》 15期 (2003/05) Pp. 37-78

https://doi.org/10.6255/JWGS.2003.15.37

摘要

許多同志研究以及同性戀者的個人故事中都指出，現身是同性戀認同發展的中心面向，而在向朋友、同事、家人現身中，向父母現身是同性戀面臨的最重要卻又最困難的挑戰。本研究總計訪談了32位從16歲到42歲的男同志，以瞭解台灣男同志與其原生家庭的關係，以及現身與否的考量、策略、時機與後果。
現身的考量主要有以父母為導向（怕父母傷心、失望）以及自利導向（怕父母不能接受，繼而影響自己的權益）的因素。現身或不現身的策略則包括1.隱藏（同性戀資訊管理、偽裝、與父母疏遠、離家）。2.降低現身的風險（增強自身的能量、降低父母對他的期望、主動提供資訊以改變父母的態度）。3.應付婚姻壓力（提出不婚論述、鼓勵兄弟結婚生子）。而現身之後父母經常探取否認的態度，或自責教養方式有誤，或質疑小孩被朋友帶壞，同性戀成為一個不能碰觸的禁忌，一道不能揭開的傷口。有的父母有程度接受，事實上是接受自己的小孩，但不能接受同性戀。父母可能仍擁有刻板印象，因此擔心小孩受到社會岐視、孤單、得到愛滋病、失去男性氣概等。只有極少數的例子，因親子關係良好，父母的態度本來也較為開放，父母會嘗試去理解同志兒子的處境，進而提供支持。

關鍵字

同性戀 ； 現身 ； 家庭 ； 污名管理

並列摘要

Many gay studies and personal stories of gay men illustrate that coming out is the central aspect of gay identify development. In addition, coming out to parents the most important and difficult challenge for gay men Thirty-two gay men, aged from 16 to 42, were interviewed in order to understand gay men’s relations with their parents as well as the decisions, strategies and consequences of coming out to parents.
According to the findings, the considerations for coming out include parents oriented (ex. hurting their feelings) and self oriented (ex. the risk of possible rejection) reasons. Gay men used the following strategies to deal with coming out, ex. hiding, reducing the risk of coming out, managing the pressure of marriage. Once coming out, their parents tended to take the attitude of denial. They either blamed themselves or suspected that their child was influenced by bad friends. Their child's being gay became a taboo, a topic that would not be discussed. Only very few parents who were open and had intimate relationship could try to understand their child's situation and try give him support.

並列關鍵字

gay men ； homosexuality ； coming out ； family ； stigma management

參考文獻

Ben-Ari, A.(1995).The discovery that an offspring is gay: Parent's, gay men's, and lesbians’ perspectives.Journal of Homosexuality.30(1),89-112.

Bohan, J. S.(1996).Psychology and sexual orientation: Coming to terms.

Cain, R.(1991).Relations contexts and information management among gay men.Families in Society.72(6),344-352.

Cramer, D. W.,Roach, A. J.(1988).Coming out to mom and dad: A study of gay males and their relationships with their parents.Journal of Homosexuality.15(3)/15(4),79-91.

Despres, C.(1991).The meaning of home: Literature review and directionsl for future research and theoretical development.Journal of Architectural and Planning Research.8(2),96-115.