類比故事的表面特徵與結構特徵在不同年齡層對故事回想表現的影響

The Effects of Superficial and Structure Feature Match on Story Recall Performance of Students at Different Ages

陳茹玲(Ju-Ling Chen) ； 蘇宜芬(Yi-Fen Su)

《教育心理學報》 37卷2期 (2005/12) Pp. 123-146

https://doi.org/10.6251/BEP.20051024

摘要

本研究包括兩個實驗，「實驗一」旨在探討台灣的大學生在閱讀故事時，類比故事的表面特徵與結構特徵對故事回想表現之影響，實驗二旨在探討國小四年級、國小六年級、國中二年級學生在閱讀故事時，其故事的回想表現受到表面特徵與結構特徵的影響程度是否與大學生不同。實驗一對象為120名大學生，實驗二對象為129名大學生，136名國二學生，132名國小六年級，130名國小四年級學生。研究結果顯示：一、類比故事的表面相似程度或結構相似程度越高時，學生的故事回想表現越佳。二、類比表現有發展上的差異。國小四年級學童的故事回想表現與其他年齡層不同，隨著年齡增加，學生的故事回想表現越好。三、不同年齡層學生的故事回想比率組型不同。大學生對於表面相似程度與結構相似程度反應最敏銳。國二學生的反應組型與大學生相似。小六與小四學生對於表面相似程度與結構相似程度的反應分化程度最低。

關鍵字

類比 ； 類比歷程 ； 表面特徵 ； 結構特徵 ； 故事回想表現

並列摘要

The main purpose of this research was to investigate the effects of superficial feature and structural feature match of analogical stories on students' story recall performance, and explore whether the effects varied with age differences. The findings are as follows: First, the result suggested that both superficial feature and structural feature may influence story recall performance. The better the two features matched, the better the story was recalled. However, there was no interaction between the two factors. Secondly, the effects of superficial feature and structural feature match on story recall performance changed with age. The recall performance of the fourth graders was significantly lower than other age groups. The performance of story recall improved with age. Thirdly, the recall patterns of different age groups were different. College students showed the strongest sensitivity to superficial feature match and structural feature match. Junior high school students showed similar story recall patterns with college students, but they were not as sensitive to superfical feature match and structural feature match as college students were. The sixth and fourth graders showed much less sensitirity to superficial feature match and structural feature match than college students and junior high school students did.

並列關鍵字

analogy ； the process of analogy ； superficial feature ； structural feature ； story recall performance

參考文獻

Blanchette, I.,Dunbar, K.(2000).How analogies are generated: The role of structural and superficial similarity.Memory & Cognition.28,108-124.

Blanchette, I.,Dunbar, K.(2002).Representational change and analogy: How analogical inferences alter target representations.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning , Memory , and Cognition.25(4),672-685.

Catrambone, R.(1998).The subgoal learning model and problem-solving transfer: Creating better examples so that students can solve novel problem.Journal of Experimental Psychology: General,.127,355-376.

Catrambone, R.(2002).The effects of surface and structural feature matches on the access of story analogs.Journal of Experimental Psychology.28(2),318-334.

Catrambone, R.,Holyoak, K. J.(1989).Overcome limitation on problem transfer.Journal of Experimental Psychology.75(6),1147-1156.