教師專業發展評鑑與專業學習社群之個案研究

A case study of Teacher evaluation for professional development and professional learning communities

沈靜濤(Ching-Tao Shen)

指導教授 ： 潘慧玲

國立臺灣師範大學/教育學院/教育學系/碩士(2009年)

摘要

本研究係以一所推動「試辦教師專業發展評鑑」的國中為個案，以各領域所形成的專業學習社群為焦點，瞭解該校推動「試辦教師專業發展評鑑」的方式，並透過Huffman引用Fullan的學校革新階段理論為基礎，分析該校各領域教師因教師專業發展評鑑而形成的專業學習社群之演進歷程與特性，以探討教師專業發展評鑑推動歷程中專業學習社群之發展。
本研究採用文件分析、現場觀察與訪談，並將所蒐集的資料進行相互檢證，以形成研究的發現與結果，依據研究目的與問題獲致研究之結論如下：
一、 依循政策指引與掌握學校既有的條件與參與經驗，是太陽國中試辦教師專業發展評鑑的背景與推動方式。
二、 領域本位的規劃與實施，是太陽國中形成教師專業發展評鑑目標、修訂評鑑規準與運用評鑑結果的方式。
三、 太陽國中的專業學習社群歷經了初始階段的「對話」與「分享」，以及執行階段的「行動」與「實踐」。
四、 「領導作為」、「社群願景」以及「團隊合作方式」為太陽國中專業學習社群演進歷程所呈現的共同特性。
（一） 支持與分享的領導作為，是學校中專業學習社群各演進階段的特性。
（二） 社群願景的形塑，是專業學習社群執行階段的特性，而團隊合作方式則是貫串各演進階段的特性。
基於上述結論，本研究對學校行政單位、國民小學教師及後續研究提出下列建議：
一、對學校行政單位的建議
（一）展現學校領導者專業領導的能力，以深厚學校的專業學習社群。
（二）擴大教師參與學校事務的機會，以增進教師對評鑑活動的認同。
二、對學校教師參與試辦的建議
（一）接納教師專業發展評鑑，促進教師專業學習社群的發展。
（二）善用專業學習社群的影響力，有助於學校推動教師專業發展評鑑。
三、對後續研究的建議
（一）針對學校中的專業學習社群進行實徵性的研究。
（二）進一步研究教師專業發展評鑑擴大推動對學校專業學習社群之影響。

關鍵字

教師評鑑 ； 教師專業發展 ； 教師專業發展評鑑 ； 專業學習社群

並列摘要

The purpose of this study is to understand the promotion of the trial teacher evaluation for professional development through investigating the professional learn ing communities of each learning area in a secondary school. Furthermore, based on Fullan’s stage theory of school change which is cited by Huffman, this study analyzes the process and the characteristic of professional learning communities in each learn ing area of this case school to explore the growth of professional learning communities in the progress of teacher evaluation for professional development.
Research methods of documentary analysis, observation and interview are adopt ed in this study, and besides, the findings and results are revealed from the examin ation and cross-analysis among the collected data. The conclusions of this study are as the following:
a.The context and the trial way to put teacher evaluation for professional development into practice to follow the policy directions and grasp the conditions and given experiences of the Solar Junior High School
b.The planning and implementation of the area-based is the way of forming the evaluation objective of teacher professional development, revising the evaluation regulation and applying evaluation results in the Solar Junior High School.
c.The professional learning community of Solar Junior High School has gone through the "Dialogue" and "Sharing" in the initial phase, as well as the "Action" and "Practice" in the implementation phase.
d.The leadership style, community vision and team cooperation are the supporting conditions and feasibility characteristic of professional learning communities.
(a)The supportive and sharing leadership styles are the supporting conditions of professional learning communities.
(b)The shape of the community vision is the feasibility characteristic of the professional learning communities, while team cooperation serves as the core characteristic factor for the overall progress of professional learning communities.
Based on the conclusions above, the suggestions of this study for the education administration authorities, school administration, primary school teachers and future researches are proposed as below:
a.The suggestions on school administration
(a)Develop the professional leaderships of the leaders to strengthen school’s profess ional learning communities.
(b)Offer more opportunities for teachers to participate in school affairs to improve th eir identification of evaluations.
b.The suggestions on school teachers participate in teacher evaluation for professional devel opment.
(a)Accept teacher evaluation for professional development to deepen teachers’ profes sional learning communities.
(b)Take advantage of the influences of professional learning communities to promote teacher evaluation for professional development
c.The suggestions on future researches
(a)Engage in empirical studies focused on professional learning communities in scho ols.
(b)Make the further investigations into the influences on schools’ professional learnin g communities while promoting teacher evaluation for professional development formally.

並列關鍵字

teacher evaluation ； teacher professional development ； teacher evalua tion for professional development ； professional learning community

參考文獻

周啟葶（2006）。以「學習社群」促進教師專業發展之分析。中等教育，57（5），94-113。

林劭仁（2006）。專業學習社群運用於師資培育自我評鑑之探究。中正教育研究，5（2），79-111。

洪劭品（2006）。臺北市縣國民小學教師對教育部試辦教師專業發展評鑑意見之研究。國立新竹教育大學教育學系碩士班，未出版，新竹市。

孫志麟（2008）。學校本位教師評鑑的實踐與反思。教育實踐與研究，21（2）， 63-94。

高博銓（2008）。學校學習社群的發展與挑戰。中等教育，59（4），8-20。