預算控制與管理會計系統是否能提昇產品創新績效？

How Can Budget Control and Management Accounting System Improve Product Innovation Performance?

鄭國枝(Kuo-Chih Cheng) ； 楊美玲(Mei-Ling Yang) ； 蘇錦俊(Chin-Chun Su) ； 丁念茹(Nien-Ju Ting)

《中山管理評論》 21卷3期 (2013/09) Pp. 545-577

https://doi.org/10.6160/2013.09.03

摘要

先前文獻對於預算控制程度高低對產品創新績效間的關係各有不同主張。本研究認為預算控制與產品創新績效間的關係為一倒U型曲線，適中預算控制才能達到最佳產品創新績效企業，採取寬鬆預算控制與嚴格預算控制均無法達到最佳產品創新績效，此結果解決了先前文獻中的爭辯。再者，台灣高科技產業因應全球競爭，預算控制程度未來將更趨嚴格，高品質管理會計資訊能提供高預算控制下攸關與可靠之資訊，對產品創新績效產生正向影響。本研究以台灣證券交易所與櫃檯買賣中心之高科技公司135位研發經理人為問卷調查對象，研究方法採用曲線迴歸分析與調節迴歸分析，實證結果完全支持本研究假說，預算控制與產品創新績效之間的關係為一倒U型曲線。此外，當在高預算控制下����管理會計資訊對產品創新績效有正向且顯著之影響，但於低 預算控制下，對產品創新績效無顯著影響。本研究並提出未來研究方法與管理意涵。

關鍵字

預算控制 ； 產品創新 ； 研發經理人 ； 管理會計系統

並列摘要

Previous literatures have differing opinions on the relationship between budget control and product innovation performance. Proponents of the low level of budget control argue that it permits companies to experiment with new strategies and innovative projects in a more resourced environment. Proponents of the high level of budget control counter that the low level of budget control promotes undisciplined and diminished incentives to product innovation performance. Results from a questionnaire survey of 135 R&D managers with budget responsibilities in high-tech manufacturing companies, which were listed in the Taiwan Stock Exchange Market, provide part support for these predictions. Curve regression analysis and moderated regression analysis are used and the results support our hypotheses. The findings of this study support our expectation that management accounting system has a positive and significant influence on product innovation performance when the level of budget control is high, but has no significant effect when the level of budget control is low. In a less resourced environment, management accounting system is required to capture and reflect the information that managers require for the more effective operation of product innovation processes.

並列關鍵字

Budget control ； Product innovation ； R&D manager ； Management accounting system

參考文獻

蔡惠丞、盧正宗、林麗霞、倪豐裕，2008，「內外控人格特質對產品創新、管理會計 資訊系統與組織績效間關係影響之探討」，人文暨社會科學期刊，4卷2期： 61~70。

鍾紹熙、倪豐裕、蘇英芳、邱炳乾、蘇錦俊，2009，「策略型態對廣範圍管會系統、 工作資訊認知與管理績效之關聯性的影響」，交大管理學報，29卷2期：47~82。

倪豐裕、莊曜愷、邱炳乾，2006，「知覺任務不確定性、組織承諾、管理會計資訊系 統三者對管理績效交互作用之影響」，管理與系統，13卷1期：1~14。

Abernethy, M. A. and Guthrie, C. H., 1994, “An Empirical Assessment of the “Fit” between Strategy and Management Information System Design,” Accounting and Finance, Vol. 34, No. 2, 49-66.

Antle, R. and Fellingham, J., 1990, “Resource Rationing and Organizational Slack in a Two Period Model,” Journal of Accounting Research, Vol. 28, No. 1, 1-24.